Vinyl Review

Bruce Springsteen : The Album Collection Vol. 2, 1987-1996 : 2018

By ·

Bruce Springsteen : The Album Collection Vol. 2, 1987-1996 : 2018

Label: Columbia / Legacy Recordings Format: 10-LP deluxe box set Released: May 18, 2018

Overview

If The Album Collection Vol. 1 captured Bruce Springsteen’s ascent from scrappy Jersey Shore songwriter to the biggest rock star in America, Vol. 2 documents the decade where he deliberately, almost stubbornly, walked away from that persona. This box gathers the five studio and live albums Springsteen released for Columbia between 1987 and 1996 — Tunnel of Love, Human Touch, Lucky Town, In Concert/MTV Plugged, and The Ghost of Tom Joad — plus two bonus EPs, Chimes of Freedom (1988) and Blood Brothers (1996), the latter making its first-ever appearance on vinyl here. All ten discs were long out of print on the format, remastered from the original analog masters by Bob Ludwig working with Springsteen’s longtime engineer Toby Scott, using the same Plangent Process tape-playback system employed on Vol. 1.

This is, by design, the least beloved stretch of Springsteen’s catalog — the period where he broke up the E Street Band, moved to Los Angeles, released two competing albums on the same day, and eventually retreated into stark solo acoustic songwriting. Even sympathetic critics tend to treat this decade as a fascinating detour rather than a creative peak. But taken as a whole, the box tells a genuinely compelling story: an artist working through divorce, remarriage, fatherhood, and a prolonged commercial and creative identity crisis in full public view, before landing on some of the most quietly powerful songwriting of his career on The Ghost of Tom Joad.

Tunnel of Love (1987)

Springsteen’s most personal record to date, written and largely recorded alone in his home studio as his first marriage was dissolving. It’s stripped of E Street Band bombast in favor of drum machines, synthesizers, and an unusually confessional lyrical voice.

  1. Ain’t Got You — A wry, a cappella-adjacent opener about the emptiness of fame and fortune without love.
  2. Tougher Than the Rest — A steely, mid-tempo statement of romantic resolve; one of the album’s most enduring deep cuts, especially beloved in Europe.
  3. All That Heaven Will Allow — Warm and buoyant, a rare moment of uncomplicated contentment on an otherwise conflicted record.
  4. Spare Parts — A stark, socially conscious narrative about a young single mother, delivered with some of the album’s most vivid storytelling.
  5. Cautious Man — A quiet, haunted character study of a man torn between commitment and the urge to run.
  6. Walk Like a Man — A tender meditation on fatherhood and inherited masculinity, written around Springsteen’s own wedding.
  7. Tunnel of Love — The title track and a Grammy winner, using a carnival ride as a metaphor for the unknowable terrain of a long relationship.
  8. Two Faces — Moody and self-doubting, capturing the record’s undercurrent of anxiety about commitment.
  9. Brilliant Disguise — The album’s biggest hit and emotional centerpiece: a devastating meditation on the impossibility of ever truly knowing another person, or oneself.
  10. One Step Up — A weary, atmospheric song about a marriage quietly falling apart; one of the most emotionally direct songs Springsteen ever wrote.
  11. When You’re Alone — A pointed, cautionary song about the loneliness that follows a broken relationship.
  12. Valentine’s Day — A gentle, reflective closer that ends the album on a note of hard-won tenderness rather than resolution.

Human Touch (1992)

Released the same day as Lucky Town, recorded with session musicians rather than the E Street Band, and widely regarded as the more polished, less inspired of Springsteen’s two 1992 albums.

  1. Human Touch — The title track and lead single, a big, anthemic statement about needing connection despite being burned before.
  2. Soul Driver — A slick, mid-tempo rocker that leans into the album’s more radio-friendly ’90s production style.
  3. 57 Channels (And Nothin’ On) — A darkly comic complaint about consumerist emptiness; divisive among fans, but a memorable change of pace.
  4. Cross My Heart — A loose, bluesy pledge of devotion.
  5. Gloria’s Eyes — An upbeat, guitar-driven rocker, one of the album’s more straightforwardly fun tracks.
  6. With Every Wish — A subdued, jazz-inflected ballad that stands apart from the record’s rockier material.
  7. Roll of the Dice — Co-written with pianist Roy Bittan, a driving rocker about romantic risk-taking that became an AOR radio favorite.
  8. Real World — Reflective and searching, another Bittan co-write that leans into the album’s theme of hard-won maturity.
  9. All or Nothin’ at All — A tight, uptempo rocker that keeps the album’s energy up without breaking much new ground.
  10. Man’s Job — A soulful, horn-inflected track about romantic devotion as a kind of labor.
  11. I Wish I Were Blind — A tender, string-laced ballad about willful romantic denial.
  12. The Long Goodbye — A world-weary meditation on the end of a relationship.
  13. Real Man — A wry, self-aware song about redefining masculinity away from old macho ideals.
  14. Pony Boy — A gentle, traditional-styled lullaby that closes the album on a disarmingly simple, folk-adjacent note.

Lucky Town (1992)

Recorded quickly and largely alone after Springsteen shelved plans to simply add one more song to Human Touch, Lucky Town is shorter, more stripped-down, and far more personal — widely regarded by critics as the stronger of the two 1992 releases.

  1. Better Days — A wry, hard-won statement of renewal after divorce and creative stagnation; one of the record’s best-loved tracks.
  2. Lucky Town — A loose, rambling road song about chasing a fresh start.
  3. Local Hero — A funny, self-deprecating story about seeing his own face reduced to forgotten local memorabilia.
  4. If I Should Fall Behind — A quietly beautiful vow of mutual devotion that would go on to become a live staple for decades.
  5. Leap of Faith — A joyful, gospel-tinged song about surrendering to love.
  6. The Big Muddy — A murkier, more ambiguous meditation on moral compromise.
  7. Living Proof — A powerful, redemptive song written about the birth of his first son, and one of the album’s emotional high points.
  8. Book of Dreams — A tender wedding song, warm and unguarded.
  9. Souls of the Departed — A tense, angry song inspired by the Gulf War, echoing the social commentary of “Born in the U.S.A.” in tone if not sound.
  10. My Beautiful Reward — A restless, searching closer about the elusiveness of contentment even after finding love.

In Concert/MTV Plugged (1993)

Recorded for MTV’s Unplugged series in September 1992 — though, true to the crossed-out “Un” on the cover art, Springsteen and his post-E Street touring band played almost entirely electric. A genuine curiosity: a live document from the era fans generally like least, featuring a mostly non-E Street band.

  1. Red Headed Woman — A previously unreleased, comic solo-acoustic number that opens the set on a loose, playful note.
  2. Better Days — A full-band rendition that gives the Lucky Town highlight extra muscle.
  3. Local Hero — A faithful live take of the wry Lucky Town cut.
  4. Atlantic City — A striking reinvention of the stark Nebraska original as a full electric rock arrangement.
  5. Darkness on the Edge of Town — A welcome dose of vintage E Street-era material, reworked for the new band.
  6. Man’s Job — A soulful live rendition that arguably improves on the studio cut.
  7. Growin’ Up — An early-catalog deep cut given fresh energy by the new lineup.
  8. Human Touch — A duet with wife Patti Scialfa, stretched out and given real emotional weight.
  9. Lucky Town — An energized, full-band version of the Lucky Town title track.
  10. I Wish I Were Blind — A riveting, more emotionally raw live take than the studio original.
  11. Thunder Road — A Grammy-nominated performance of the classic, reworked with the new band in place of the E Street Band.
  12. Light of Day — The set’s most explosive moment: a scorching, extended jam on the song Springsteen wrote for the 1987 film of the same name.
  13. The Big Muddy — A tighter, more driving live version of the Lucky Town cut.
  14. 57 Channels (And Nothin’ On) — A punchier live rendition of the Human Touch deep cut.
  15. My Beautiful Reward — A restrained, heartfelt closer to the main set.
  16. Glory Days — A crowd-pleasing romp through the Born in the U.S.A. hit.
  17. Living Proof — A bonus track (not aired on the original MTV broadcast), delivering real emotional heft.
  18. If I Should Fall Behind — Another bonus cut, quietly one of the best performances in the whole set.

The Ghost of Tom Joad (1995)

Springsteen’s second primarily acoustic, Steinbeck-referencing song cycle after Nebraska, and widely regarded as the strongest work of this whole era — a collection of quiet, character-driven story-songs about migrants, drifters, and forgotten American workers.

  1. The Ghost of Tom Joad — The title track, a haunting update of Steinbeck’s Grapes of Wrath imagery for the 1990s, later famously covered by Rage Against the Machine.
  2. Straight Time — A tense character study of an ex-convict struggling to stay on the right side of the law.
  3. Highway 29 — A tightly wound narrative about a doomed robbery and getaway.
  4. Youngstown — A blistering account of the collapse of American steel-town industry, arguably the album’s most direct descendant of “Born in the U.S.A.” in subject matter.
  5. Sinaloa Cowboys — A devastating story of two immigrant brothers pulled into meth production; one of the album’s most quietly harrowing tracks.
  6. The Line — A patient, morally complex story about a border patrol agent’s crisis of conscience.
  7. Balboa Park — A stark account of child sex workers on the US-Mexico border, among the bleakest material Springsteen has ever recorded.
  8. Dry Lightning — A restrained, atmospheric character sketch that lightens the album’s tone only slightly.
  9. The New Timer — An extended narrative about an aging drifter and the young man he takes under his wing.
  10. Across the Border — A gentle, hopeful ballad about the dream of a better life across the border, offering a rare note of tenderness.
  11. Galveston Bay — A tense story of post-Vietnam War tension between a Vietnamese immigrant and a local fisherman, resolved with quiet grace.
  12. My Best Was Never Good Enough — A brief, wry closer built from a string of American folk clichés, undercutting the album’s weight with dry humor.

Chimes of Freedom EP (1988)

A four-song live EP released to benefit Amnesty International’s Human Rights Now! Tour, drawn from the Tunnel of Love Express Tour.

  1. Tougher Than the Rest (live) — A muscular full-band rendition of the Tunnel of Love highlight.
  2. Be True (live) — A rare live outing for this older River-era outtake.
  3. Chimes of Freedom (live) — A faithful, horn-inflected cover of the Bob Dylan song that gives the EP its title.
  4. Born to Run (live, acoustic) — A striking reinvention of Springsteen’s signature anthem as a slowed-down acoustic ballad.

Blood Brothers EP (1996) — first vinyl pressing

Recorded during a brief 1995 E Street Band reunion for the Greatest Hits sessions, this five-song EP is a genuine rarity making its first-ever appearance on vinyl in this box.

  1. Blood Brothers (alternate studio version) — A full-band rock take on the song that appeared in acoustic form on Greatest Hits, capturing the band’s rediscovered chemistry.
  2. High Hopes — A cover of Tim Scott McConnell’s song, later re-recorded as the title track of Springsteen’s 2014 studio album.
  3. Murder Incorporated (live) — A ferocious live recording from New York club Tramps, the same performance used in the song’s music video.
  4. Secret Garden (with strings) — A fuller, string-laden version of the Greatest Hits single.
  5. Without You — A little-heard rarity that closes out the EP and the box set as a whole.

The Vinyl Itself: Pressing & Sound Quality

Reaction to this box’s actual vinyl quality has been notably more mixed than to Vol. 1. All ten records were remastered using the Plangent Process and cut from the original analog tapes, and several of the titles — particularly the earlier records like Tunnel of Love — are reported by collectors as sounding clean and dynamic. But The Ghost of Tom Joad in particular has drawn consistent complaints: because it’s such a quiet, sparse recording, persistent surface noise is far more audible than it would be on a louder rock record, and more than one buyer has reported the noise floor on this specific title as unacceptably high, with the RIAA/Legacy pressing feeling notably worse than the record’s hushed, largely solo-acoustic content deserved. Beyond that specific title, some individual copies have shipped with genuine manufacturing errors — one collector reported a Lucky Town LP where side B contained the correct audio but a mislabeled disc from In Concert/MTV Plugged.

More broadly, several owners have noted that this box didn’t quite live up to the sonic reputation of Vol. 1‘s remaster, suggesting the Plangent Process didn’t uniformly improve every title in the set the way it seemed to for the earlier box. The packaging itself is well-regarded across the board: each title is presented in a faithful recreation of its original sleeve art, and the accompanying 60-page book of photos, memorabilia, and press clippings is a genuine highlight — though a few buyers have separately noted the outer box’s glossy exterior coating tends to flake with handling over time.

Final Verdict

The Album Collection Vol. 2 is a box set for the committed rather than the curious — a comprehensive document of Springsteen’s least commercially and critically favored decade, but one that rewards patience with real gems scattered throughout (Brilliant Disguise, If I Should Fall Behind, Living Proof, and virtually all of The Ghost of Tom Joad). It’s genuinely valuable as the first legitimate vinyl reissue of most of these titles, and the previously vinyl-exclusive Blood Brothers EP is a real treat for collectors. But it’s a set best approached with tempered expectations on the pressing side: this is a mixed-quality remaster campaign rather than a flawless one, with at least one included title (The Ghost of Tom Joad) earning specific, repeated criticism for excessive surface noise. Fans who already know and love this era of Springsteen’s catalog will find plenty to enjoy here; newcomers would be better served starting with Vol. 1 or the man’s more celebrated E Street Band-era work.

Highlights: “Brilliant Disguise,” “One Step Up,” “Better Days,” “If I Should Fall Behind,” “Living Proof,” “The Ghost of Tom Joad,” “Youngstown,” “Sinaloa Cowboys”

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.