Vinyl Review

Vinyl Review

Simply the musings of the records I have bought, the tracks on them and the shops I choose to buy records from.

The intention is that my ramblings will somehow help people decide whether or not to buy a record, along with some thoughts on buying second-hand records.

There are sites that go into much more detail and offer what I shall call “stronger opinions”. My aim has always been to give my own personal opinion, unbiased by any outside influence.

I’m now trying to grow the site beyond just me. The plan is for other people to review their own collections here too, so instead of one person’s view you’ll get a range of opinions on how good a record really is. Everyone hears music differently, and I think more honest, personal views will make the site more useful. Each review will still be one person’s own take, with nobody telling them what to say.

If you’d like to share reviews of your own collection, head over to the Write for Us page to find out how to get involved.

Nine records and their sleeves arranged in a grid on a wall
“Do yourself a tremendous favour and go to a record store today. The relatively mild exertion of getting off your fat, computer-shackled ass and venturing out to find the object of your desire, the thrill of moving through actual space and time, through row upon row of records, and the tactile ecstasy of fondling the quested treasure—all this will augment and enrich the mental associations the music invokes in you for the rest of your life.”
Grinderman
A turntable playing a record

Who Spins Vinyl Review

This site is an idea I had and decided to put together for no other reason than because I can. My name is Phil, I own a small computer support company in Dorset and I like listening to Vinyl.

I don’t pretend to be an expert or even a lifelong lover of Vinyl. In fact I only rediscovered music in 2024 and did not start collecting with any purpose until late 2025. I am however very nerdy and love getting into the details so have applied a lot of my personal aptitudes to making sure what I have performs the best is possibly can.

I am rebuilding my childhood collection whilst discovering all new music I would never have considered before. Listening has become part of my world and I find it both enjoyable and an essential part of maintaining good mental health, as it makes you slow down in a world that is busy all the time, and often unrelenting in the toll it takes on your time, and your wellbeing.

From time to time other record lovers write for Vinyl Review too. Their posts show their name, and you can read about them on the Contributors page. Fancy joining them? Here’s how to become a contributor.

“For me it all started with two turntables and a mixer.”
Paul Oakenfold
“My father was my first inspiration. He had an incredible stereo and a turntable, and I was told not to touch it. But I’d go back and touch it anyway. I gained a respect for the turntables when I was a kid. When I was a teenager, I came up with a ‘cueing system’ to work the turntables because they didn’t have it at that time.”
Grandmaster Flash
“If I was a billionaire, and had my time all over, I would invest all of my money in setting up a factory to produce vinyl records again.”
Roger Daltrey

How I grade my records

I have a certain personality type. I like things to be precise where I can. When I grade my records I don’t use the grading that is supplied at time of purchase

Mint for a cover will be relevant of age. You cannot expect a 50 year old record to be truly mint. The same goes for the sleeve. That said, once a record has been played once, it cannot be called mint. Mint is unplayed. The needle, the cleaning, exposure to your space, it all stops a record being classed as truly mint.

VG. + is where a lot of my items lie. A good quality cover, sleeve and a played but unmarked record.

VG is the same as above but the vinyl itself might have a little pop and crackle.

Good + is where minor marks on the vinyl show but make so difference to the playback.

Good is as low as I can go. anything below this is a hard listen. Even at good levels, you have to love the music being played to overcome the flaws in the records condition.

I apply a 90 percent rule. If 90 percent of the record meets the criteria, then it gets that grading. Anything over than that, then it gets bumped down. I use a small sticker system on my records to indicate the quality. Just in case I forget how it sounds or to avoid a lesser record when I am showing off my listening space to friends.

Record grading chart: Mint, Near Mint, Excellent, Very Good, Good, Fair/Poor, with a description of each