Creedence Clearwater Revival : Bad Moon Rising – The Collection : 2019

UMC
LP, Comp, RE
Mint (M)
Label: UMC / Universal Music Operations (originally compiled by Spectrum Music) Format: Single LP, 15 tracksReleased: October 4, 2019 (reissue of a 2013 CD compilation) Pressed by: GZ Media
Overview
Bad Moon Rising: The Collection began life in 2013 as a budget CD compilation for Spectrum Music, and Universal quietly reissued it on vinyl in 2019 — likely riding the broader late-2010s wave of legacy-artist vinyl reissues rather than responding to any particular anniversary. It’s worth being upfront about what this is and isn’t: it is not a definitive CCR best-of, and the vinyl edition trims the CD’s already-odd 18-track sequence down to a leaner 15 for space. AllMusic’s Stephen Thomas Erlewine, reviewing the original CD, put his finger on the problem well: there are just enough hits here (“Bad Moon Rising,” “Green River,” “Proud Mary”) to remind you how many aren’t — no “Who’ll Stop the Rain,” no “Travelin’ Band,” no “Lodi.” What you get instead is a hits-plus-deep-cuts hybrid that will satisfy nobody chasing a true singles collection, but that has some genuine appeal for anyone who already owns Chronicle and wants a cheap single-disc dose of the album tracks and rarities.
The band’s four-year run (1968–1972) remains one of the most stacked in American rock history, and even a slightly haphazard compilation like this one is hard to make bad — Fogerty’s songwriting was simply that consistent. But this is a collection for the curious or the budget-conscious rather than the definitive word on the band’s singles.
Track by Track
Side One
- Born on the Bayou (from Bayou Country, 1969) — A strong, atmospheric opener; all murky swamp groove and one of Fogerty’s most evocative vocal performances. A smart choice to lead the record even though it was never a huge chart single.
- Bad Moon Rising (from Green River, 1969) — The title track and the record’s biggest hit: two minutes of deceptively cheerful apocalypse, built on one of Fogerty’s catchiest riffs.
- Green River (from Green River, 1969) — Tight, driving, and one of the all-time great examples of the band’s “swamp rock” style, despite being written about a real creek in Iowa rather than the Louisiana bayou it evokes.
- Up Around the Bend (from Cosmo’s Factory, 1970) — Bright, urgent, and one of the band’s most purely fun singles; the guitar hook alone justifies its inclusion.
- Sweet Hitch-Hiker (from Mardi Gras, 1972) — A late-period single, harder-edged and less remembered than the band’s classic-era work, but a decent, punchy inclusion from an album (Mardi Gras) that’s otherwise mostly skipped on compilations.
- Fortunate Son (Live) — An interesting curveball: rather than the famous Willy and the Poor Boys studio cut, this compilation opts for a live version, giving the song a rawer, more ragged edge than most listeners will be used to.
- Chameleon (from Pendulum, 1970) — A genuine deep-cut choice, and a good one: a soulful, horn-and-electric-piano-driven groove that shows the band stretching beyond straight swamp rock in their later, more experimental period.
- Proud Mary (from Bayou Country, 1969) — Arguably the best-known song the band ever recorded, and it closes side one on the collection’s highest note; the riverboat lope and the “rollin'” chorus still land perfectly.
Side Two
- Have You Ever Seen the Rain? (from Pendulum, 1970) — A gorgeous, deceptively simple ballad; one of Fogerty’s best melodies and a strong way to open the second side.
- Lookin’ Out My Back Door (from Cosmo’s Factory, 1970) — Playful, countrified, and one of the sunniest songs in the catalog; a welcome change of pace after the more brooding songs around it.
- Someday Never Comes (from Mardi Gras, 1972) — A reflective, semi-autobiographical song about fatherhood and disillusionment; one of the more mature, adult moments from the band’s twilight period.
- Bootleg (from Bayou Country, 1969) — A loose, bluesy groove that’s long been a fan favorite despite never being a single; a good example of the album-track strength that makes even this odd compilation worthwhile.
- It’s Just a Thought (from Pendulum, 1970) — Moody and slow-building, this one leans into the more contemplative, R&B-inflected sound the band was chasing on their later albums.
- Cotton Fields (from Willy and the Poor Boys, 1969) — A joyful, banjo-flecked cover of the Lead Belly folk standard, and a reminder of how well the band could reinterpret older American folk and blues material.
- Keep On Chooglin’ (Live) — A sprawling, nine-minute live jam that closes the record on an extended, loose-limbed note — a good showcase for the band’s chemistry as a live act, though its length relative to the rest of the tracklist makes it feel like a strange way to end what’s otherwise a compilation of tight, economical songs.
The Vinyl Itself: Pressing & Sound Quality
This is a budget legacy reissue, not an audiophile release, and it should be judged on those terms. It was pressed by GZ Media in the Czech Republic, a high-volume plant that presses a huge share of the world’s reissue vinyl and has a mixed-but-generally-serviceable reputation depending on the title and pressing run. Given how packed each side is — Side One alone carries eight songs, and Side Two closes with a nine-minute live track — there was some real risk of the grooves being crammed too tightly for good dynamics, which can compress low-end punch and add surface noise on busy compilation LPs.
In practice, listener reports have been more positive than that setup might suggest: collectors have specifically noted being surprised by how good it sounds given both the GZ pressing and the amount of audio squeezed onto each side, describing it as clean, flat, and free of major issues. The packaging itself is unfussy — a simple single-LP sleeve without much in the way of extras, sometimes accompanied by a digital download card, though this is inconsistent across copies. This is very much a “put the needle down and enjoy the music” pressing rather than a deluxe collector’s item, but for a budget-tier legacy release it’s a pleasant surprise rather than a disappointment.
Final Verdict
As a single-disc snapshot of Creedence Clearwater Revival, Bad Moon Rising: The Collection is an odd, slightly frustrating listen for anyone expecting a proper singles collection, but a rewarding one for anyone willing to take it on its own terms. The hits are genuinely great, the deep cuts (“Chameleon,” “It’s Just a Thought,” “Bootleg”) are well-chosen and show real range, and the live tracks add some texture you won’t find on the more predictable comps. It’s let down mainly by curation logic that’s hard to parse — why include a live “Fortunate Son” instead of the classic studio cut, and why give a full third of side two to a nine-minute jam? — and by the simple fact that far better single-disc and multi-disc CCR compilations already exist. But at its price point, and pressed better than a lot of similarly budget-tier reissues, this is a perfectly enjoyable way to spend thirty-odd minutes with one of American rock’s great short-lived bands — just not the first (or even second) place a new fan should start.
Highlights: “Born on the Bayou,” “Green River,” “Bad Moon Rising,” “Have You Ever Seen the Rain?,” “Proud Mary,” “Chameleon”