Vinyl Review

Evanescence : Fallen : 2023

By ·

Evanescence : Fallen : 2023

Label: Craft Recordings (originally Wind-up Records) Format: 2LP, triple gatefold rainbow-foil jacket (also issued as splatter vinyl and in a limited Super Deluxe box set) Originally released: March 4, 2003 Reissued: November 17, 2023

Overview

Fallen is Evanescence’s major-label debut and one of the defining rock albums of the early 2000s — a record that fused Amy Lee’s classically trained, operatic vocal power with Ben Moody’s heavy, nu-metal-adjacent guitar work and a persistent gothic, string-laden sense of drama. Anchored by “Bring Me to Life,” a Grammy-winning single whose male rap-rock guest vocal (courtesy of Paul McCoy of 12 Stones) became as iconic as it was divisive, the album went on to become a genuine commercial phenomenon: certified Diamond in the US, with more than 17 million copies sold worldwide, and ranked among the best-selling albums of the 21st century. Its blend of hard rock heaviness and orchestral gothic balladry — most memorably on the ubiquitous “My Immortal” — carved out a template that few rock bands before or since have matched commercially.

This 20th-anniversary edition, released through Craft Recordings (with Amy Lee personally overseeing the reissue, including a handwritten foreword), presents a newly remastered version of the original eleven-track album on the first LP, paired with a second LP of bonus material — previously unreleased demos, live recordings, and rare B-sides, including a demo version of “Bring Me to Life” that had circulated only among dedicated fans and bootleg traders prior to this release. It arrived across several vinyl configurations: a standard black 2LP, a limited splatter-vinyl edition, and — via a separately released, more expensive Super Deluxe box set — a black/silver/white color-blend pressing bundled with a bonus cassette of demos and voice notes.

Track by Track

LP1, Side A (Original Album, Remastered)

  1. Going Under — A hard-charging, riff-driven opener that immediately establishes the record’s fusion of metal-adjacent heaviness and Lee’s soaring, classically trained vocal delivery.
  2. Bring Me to Life (featuring Paul McCoy) — The album’s signature song and biggest hit: a Grammy-winning anthem built on dramatic piano, crunching guitars, and a divisive but inescapable male rap-rock vocal counterpoint that helped make the song a genuine cultural phenomenon.
  3. Everybody’s Fool — A tense, sardonic track skewering manufactured pop stardom and superficiality, driven by one of the album’s catchiest, most aggressive riffs.
  4. My Immortal — The album’s other defining moment: a stripped-back, piano-and-strings ballad about grief and haunting loss that became one of the most enduringly popular rock ballads of its era, largely due to Lee’s raw, unadorned vocal performance.
  5. Haunted — A moody, atmospheric track that leans into the album’s gothic, string-laden textures with real restraint.
  6. Tourniquet — A dark, spiritually charged song dealing with themes of self-harm and salvation, delivered with some of the album’s heaviest instrumental weight.

LP1, Side B (Original Album, Remastered)

  1. Imaginary — A dreamlike, orchestral track (an earlier version of which first appeared on the band’s pre-major-label EP) that showcases the more fantastical, escapist side of Lee’s songwriting.
  2. Taking Over Me — A tense, driving track about emotional obsession, balancing hard rock aggression with the album’s melodic instincts.
  3. Hello — A quiet, haunting, largely piano-and-vocal track that strips the album’s drama down to its most intimate register.
  4. My Last Breath — A dramatic, string-swept track that builds to one of the record’s most theatrical, all-consuming choruses.
  5. Whisper — The album’s extended, quasi-operatic closer, building from a hushed, chant-like intro into a sweeping, symphonic finale that ties together the record’s gothic and metal influences into its most ambitious single track.

LP2, Sides C & D (Bonus Material)

  1. My Immortal (Band Version) — An alternate, full-band arrangement of the signature ballad, giving longtime fans a chance to hear the song without its familiar stripped-back arrangement.
  2. Breathe No More — A rare B-side from the Fallen era, offering a glimpse of material that didn’t make the original album’s final tracklist.
  3. Farther Away — Another period rarity, continuing the bonus disc’s excavation of contemporaneous non-album material.
  4. Missing — A further B-side/rarity, rounding out the reissue’s collection of previously hard-to-find recordings.
  5. My Immortal (Strings Version) — Yet another alternate arrangement of the band’s biggest ballad, emphasizing the orchestral elements that were more subdued in the album version.

(The remainder of side D and the bonus disc, which varies slightly between the standard 2LP, splatter vinyl, and box set editions, includes additional demos and live recordings from the Fallen era, including a previously unreleased early demo of “Bring Me to Life.”)

The Vinyl Itself: Pressing & Sound Quality

Reaction to this reissue’s sound quality has been largely positive, with a clear consensus that the remaster is a genuine, if not dramatic, improvement over prior vinyl editions. Multiple detailed listener comparisons — including from owners who also have the 2017 vinyl reissue and box set on hand — describe this 2023 remaster as offering a noticeably wider soundstage and somewhat fuller low end while staying faithful to the original mix’s overall character, with several reviewers specifically praising how present and clear Amy Lee’s vocals sound in the new master, particularly on “Hello.” It’s presented in a triple-gatefold rainbow-foil jacket, a packaging touch multiple reviewers have called a genuine highlight of the release.

Pressing quality, however, has been more inconsistent copy to copy. While a number of buyers report dead-quiet, essentially flawless pressings, others describe audible surface noise straight out of the sleeve, and reviewers are divided on whether colored/splatter vinyl variants perform as well as standard black pressings, with at least one reviewer pushing back explicitly against the idea that colored vinyl is inherently lower quality, arguing pressing technology has improved enough that this is no longer a reliable rule of thumb. Manufacturing origin also appears to vary between copies — some pressed in the US (Nashville) and others in the EU — without a clearly documented pattern connecting origin to quality, so this remains a title where checking your specific copy on arrival is a sensible precaution rather than assuming a uniform experience across all units.

Final Verdict

Fallen remains a genuine landmark of early-2000s rock, and the songwriting holds up remarkably well two decades on — “Bring Me to Life” and “My Immortal” are rightly the songs most people know it for, but “Everybody’s Fool,” “Taking Over Me,” and the sprawling closer “Whisper” all reward a full front-to-back listen. This 20th-anniversary edition treats the album with real care: a genuinely improved remaster, previously hard-to-find bonus rarities including an early “Bring Me to Life” demo, and handsome packaging overseen personally by Amy Lee. The main caveat is pressing consistency — while many copies sound excellent, enough buyers have reported noisier pressings that it’s worth inspecting your copy on arrival, particularly if you’ve opted for one of the colored-vinyl variants over the standard black pressing.

Highlights: “Bring Me to Life,” “My Immortal,” “Everybody’s Fool,” “Whisper,” “Taking Over Me”

Buy this record at Boiler Room Records (opens in a new tab)

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.