Vinyl Review

Helloween : March Of Time (The Best Of 40 Years) : 2025

By ·

Helloween : March Of Time (The Best Of 40 Years) : 2025

A 42-track career retrospective spanning four decades, pressed as a 5LP box set on 180g red vinyl with a bonus art print and jigsaw puzzle, on BMG/Noise Records.

Pressing Notes

  • Label/Catalogue: BMG Rights Management / Noise Records (BGRT-168253)
  • Format: 5 x 180g red vinyl LPs, gatefold box packaging with art print and puzzle
  • Mastering: Remastered by Sascha “Busy” Bühren, who also mastered the band’s 2021 self-titled album
  • Pressing plant/studio specifics: Not publicly documented in the release’s official credits at time of writing — unlike the vintage-era originals, no matrix/runout data for this pressing has surfaced yet in collector databases

LP1 – Side A

  1. Walls of Jericho/Ride the Sky — The title track from the 1985 debut, all raw speed and Kai Hansen’s untamed vocal energy. It’s a genuinely fierce opener for the whole box, and the remaster gives the guitars more bite than the notoriously thin original mix ever had.
  2. Metal Invaders — Fast, unpolished, and gleefully over-the-top — a good snapshot of the band before they discovered melody was as important as speed.
  3. Victim of Fate — From the Helloween mini-LP, moodier and more dynamic than the surrounding tracks, hinting at the more ambitious songwriting to come.
  4. How Many Tears — A genuinely epic early deep cut, sprawling for the era’s standards, and one of the clearest signs of the band’s future direction toward grander compositions.

LP1 – Side B

  1. Eagle Fly Free — One of the definitive power metal anthems, triumphant and soaring. It sounds exactly as huge here as it should.
  2. Halloween — The sprawling Keeper I epic, trimmed for compilation length but still carrying real weight and drama.
  3. A Tale That Wasn’t Right — A surprisingly poignant, melodic highlight dealing with mortality — still one of the most emotionally resonant songs in the catalogue.

LP2 – Side A

  1. Future World — Explosive and instantly memorable, arguably the band’s signature anthem, and it hits just as hard in this remaster as it always has.
  2. March of Time — The compilation’s namesake track, moody and mid-paced, with strong dynamic range that benefits from the cleaner mastering.
  3. Dr. Stein — Quirky and theatrical, with its playful “big science” hook intact and the wide stereo separation still a treat.
  4. I Want Out — A gleeful, defiant anthem and one of the catchiest things the band ever wrote — a highlight of the whole box.

LP2 – Side B

  1. Keeper of the Seven Keys — The thirteen-minute title epic, trimmed but still carrying its dramatic, multi-part structure.
  2. Kids of the Century — The first single with Andi Deris on vocals, and a genuinely strong transition point — melodic, confident, and a sign the band could survive the lineup change.
  3. Number One — Upbeat and hook-driven, showing the early Deris era finding its footing.

LP3 – Side A

  1. Windmill — A dramatic, mid-90s deep cut with strong dynamic shifts.
  2. Sole Survivor — Melodic and driving, a good example of the band’s mid-90s creative rebound.
  3. Perfect Gentleman — Groove-forward and hook-laden, catchy without being lightweight.
  4. In the Middle of a Heartbeat — A more reflective, mid-tempo track that breaks up the pacing nicely.
  5. Why? — Aggressive and purposeful, closing out a strong first side of this era.

LP3 – Side B

  1. Forever and One (Neverland) — One of the band’s most beloved ballads, warm and emotionally direct — a genuine high point of the whole compilation.
  2. Power — Anthemic and driving, built for arena singalongs.
  3. Steel Tormentor — Heavier and more aggressive, a good contrast to the surrounding melodic material.
  4. Hey Lord! — Upbeat and hook-heavy, representative of the band’s late-90s commercial peak.
  5. I Can — A strong, melodic closer for this side, carrying real emotional weight.

LP4 – Side A

  1. If I Could Fly — Melodic and mid-tempo, a solid if less essential entry from the band’s more experimental period.
  2. Mr. Torture — Aggressive and hook-driven, a fan favorite from this era.
  3. Hell Was Made in Heaven — Heavier production, reflecting the band’s late-90s/2000s sonic shift.
  4. Light the Universe — Notable for its guest vocal from Blackmore’s Night’s Candice Night, giving it a distinct character among the surrounding tracks.
  5. The Invisible Man — Anthemic and confident, one of the stronger Legacy-era cuts included here.

LP4 – Side B

  1. As Long as I Fall — Modern and tightly produced, showing the band’s more contemporary sonic palette.
  2. Kill It — Aggressive and direct, a solid mid-2000s deep cut.
  3. Where the Sinners Go — Melodic with a darker edge, representative of the band’s more mature 2000s songwriting.
  4. Are You Metal? — Playful and self-aware, a fun genre-celebration track that doesn’t take itself too seriously.
  5. Nabataea — Atmospheric and more expansive, closing out this side on a slightly more ambitious note.

LP5 – Side A

  1. Straight Out of Hell — Modern, punchy production with the band’s classic melodic instincts intact.
  2. Waiting for the Thunder — Anthemic and driving, a strong 2010s-era inclusion.
  3. Heroes — Melodic and triumphant, built for big choruses.
  4. My God-Given Right — Confident and hook-forward, representative of the band’s later Deris-era work.
  5. Pumpkins United — Marking the historic 2016 reunion with Kiske and Hansen, this carries real significance beyond just the song itself — a genuine full-circle moment for the catalogue.

LP5 – Side B

  1. Best Time — From the acclaimed 2021 self-titled album, upbeat and celebratory, benefiting directly from Sascha Bühren’s mastering continuity with the original album.
  2. Fear of the Fallen — Heavier and more dramatic, a highlight of the reunion-era material.
  3. Skyfall — A fitting closer for the whole box — modern, confident, and a strong note to end four decades of music on.

Verdict

Track by track, this is a well-curated, if inevitably incomplete, tour through Helloween’s history — the hits are all present and correctly sequenced roughly chronologically, letting you hear the band’s evolution across a single sitting in a way streaming playlists rarely capture. The consistency of Sascha Bühren’s remastering work across such wildly different production eras is the real technical achievement here, and the red vinyl pressing itself has been well-received for being clean and quiet. A strong, collector-friendly overview, even if the format’s clean modern production removes a little of the grit that vintage-era fans might romanticize.

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.