Led Zeppelin : Mothership : 2015

Originally released in 2007 as a career-spanning 24-track compilation selected and sequenced by the surviving band members themselves, Mothership got a fresh vinyl pressing in 2015, using the new 2014/2015 96kHz/24-bit remasters supervised by Jimmy Page. This edition arrives as a 4LP box set on 180g vinyl, half-speed mastered by Stan Ricker and pressed at RTI, housed in an embossed box with a 20-page booklet featuring liner notes from David Fricke and cover art by Shepard Fairey.
The Pressing
Opinions here are genuinely split. The packaging is consistently praised as meticulous — the embossed box, the protective layering of records and booklet, and the overall presentation have drawn real admiration, and several listeners who compared it directly against vintage 70s pressings found it held up impressively well, particularly in the high end, described by more than one reviewer as clear and crisp. But there’s a recurring critique worth taking seriously: because this compilation draws from the same digital remaster used across CD and streaming, some longtime collectors feel the sound has a slightly compressed, less analog character than original vinyl pressings of the individual albums — especially in busier passages, where instrument separation and vocal presence can suffer. A few reviews go further, calling the results “compressed and lifeless” next to the originals. It’s also worth remembering this is a singles compilation, not a fresh cut of the albums themselves — if you already own the recent deluxe studio reissues, you’re not getting new sonic ground, just a curated highlights reel in a handsome box.
LP1 – Side A
- Good Times Bad Times — A tight, punchy opener that wastes no time announcing the band’s arrival — John Bonham’s famously intricate kick-drum work is the real star here, and the crisp high end on this pressing serves his playing well.
- Communication Breakdown — Fast, aggressive, and barely over two minutes, this is early Zeppelin at its most direct — a good early test of how well the pressing handles raw, high-energy guitar work.
- Dazed and Confused — Moody and expansive, built around Page’s iconic bowed-guitar section. The extended instrumental passages benefit from whatever dynamic headroom the mastering allows, and this pressing handles the quieter, more atmospheric sections reasonably well.
- Babe I’m Gonna Leave You — A dramatic folk-rock epic with huge dynamic swings between hushed verses and explosive choruses. This is one of the tracks where a few listeners have noted the vocal presence feels slightly reduced compared to vintage pressings, though the contrast itself still lands.
LP1 – Side B
- Whole Lotta Love — One of the band’s most recognizable anthems, built on a monster riff and a genuinely chaotic psychedelic breakdown mid-track. It’s reliably one of the disc’s most satisfying listens regardless of any mastering debate — the riff simply cuts through.
- Ramble On — Melodic and folk-tinged, offering a welcome tonal shift after the heavier tracks preceding it. Plant’s vocal has real warmth here, and the acoustic-electric interplay comes through clearly.
- Heartbreaker — Riff-heavy and aggressive, featuring one of Page’s most celebrated unaccompanied guitar solos. It’s a strong side-closer, with the guitar tone retaining plenty of bite.
- Immigrant Song — A blistering, instantly recognizable closer for the LP, built around Plant’s iconic wail and a relentless, driving riff. It’s a genuinely thrilling way to end the record, and the vocal cuts through cleanly even in the busier mix moments.
LP2 – Side A
- Since I’ve Been Loving You — A slow-burning blues epic and one of the band’s most emotionally intense performances. This is one of the tracks specifically flagged by some listeners as losing a touch of nuance in busier mix sections, though the track’s core power still comes through.
- Rock and Roll — Pure, uptempo energy with a driving piano-adjacent groove — this translates well regardless of mastering concerns, and it’s a genuine highlight of the whole set for sheer momentum.
- Black Dog — A genre-defining riff built on an unusual call-and-response structure between Plant’s vocal and the band’s instrumental stabs. It’s tight and punchy here, with good separation between the vocal and the rhythm section.
LP2 – Side B
- When the Levee Breaks — Atmospheric and bass-heavy, anchored by Bonham’s cavernous, reverb-drenched drum sound — one of the most sampled drum breaks in music history. That drum sound remains a genuine highlight even on a more digitally-sourced master.
- Stairway to Heaven — The band’s best-known epic, spanning acoustic beginnings through to an explosive electric finale. The dynamics between its quiet opening and its climactic solo are generally well served by this pressing, giving the build real impact.
- The Song Remains the Same — Bright, driving, and guitar-forward, a solid way to close out the LP with energy intact.
LP3 – Side A
- Over the Hills and Far Away — Melodic and dynamic, opening acoustically before building into a fuller arrangement — a good showcase of the band’s range beyond straight hard rock.
- D’yer Mak’er — Playful and reggae-inflected, a genuine change of pace that shows the band’s willingness to experiment. It’s a fun, groove-driven listen that benefits from a clean low end.
- No Quarter — Atmospheric, slow-building, and texturally rich, built around John Paul Jones’s eerie keyboard work. It’s one of the more demanding tracks to master well, and this pressing handles its moodier textures reasonably faithfully.
LP3 – Side B
- Trampled Under Foot — Funky and propulsive, driven by a relentless keyboard riff and a tight rhythm section — the low end here has real presence, suiting the track’s groove-forward energy.
- Houses of the Holy — Upbeat and hook-driven, a fairly straightforward rock cut that provides a good energy lift heading toward the side’s grand finale.
- Kashmir — The set’s most orchestral, ambitious moment, built on a hypnotic, exotic-sounding riff and sweeping string arrangements. It’s a genuine highlight of the whole box, and the pressing’s clarity in the high end pays real dividends on the strings and cymbal work.
LP4 – Side A
- Nobody’s Fault But Mine — Riff-heavy and aggressive, representative of the band’s later, heavier period, with a tight, propulsive rhythm section.
- Achilles Last Stand — Sprawling and ambitious, one of the band’s most demanding compositions to mix and master given its layered guitar overdubs and constantly shifting dynamics. Reactions to how well this particular track holds up on this pressing have been mixed, with some feeling the density gets a little congested.
LP4 – Side B
- In the Evening — Moody and atmospheric, building from a droning intro into a full-throated rock arrangement — it closes out the main sequence with real emotional weight.
- All of My Love — A fitting, tender closer for the whole collection, built around swelling synths and one of Plant’s most heartfelt vocal performances. It’s an emotionally resonant way to end 24 tracks of career-spanning material.
Final Verdict
Mothership remains a genuinely well-curated introduction to Led Zeppelin’s catalogue, and as a single-box overview of the band’s essential singles, the song selection is close to unimpeachable. As a specific pressing, though, this 2015 edition is more of a handsome, well-packaged convenience than an audiophile event — the half-speed mastering and RTI pressing deliver clean, quiet vinyl, but the underlying digital remaster leaves some longtime collectors feeling it can’t quite match the immediacy of vintage original pressings of the individual studio albums. For casual fans or anyone without the deluxe studio reissues already on their shelf, this is a great way in. For dedicated collectors who already own those albums on vinyl, it’s a nice-looking package that doesn’t offer much you don’t already have.