Vinyl Review

Marvin Gaye : What’s Going On : 1971

By ·

Marvin Gaye : What’s Going On : 1971

Marvin Gaye – What’s Going On (1971 Vinyl)

Released May 21, 1971, on Tamla (catalogue TS-310), What’s Going On is widely regarded as Marvin Gaye’s masterpiece and one of the greatest albums in American popular music — a genuinely radical departure from Motown’s assembly-line pop sound, blending soul, jazz, and orchestral arrangements into a cohesive song cycle addressing war, poverty, and social justice. Produced entirely by Gaye himself, recorded at Hitsville U.S.A., Golden World, and United Sound in Detroit and The Sound Factory in Los Angeles, with orchestral arrangements conducted by David Van DePitte and members of the Detroit Symphony Orchestra.

The Pressing Original 1971 Tamla pressings are consistently praised by collectors, and this remains one of the most beloved original pressings in soul music — listeners describe the sound as full, detailed, and genuinely warm, with clear vocals and bass that sits right up front alongside Gaye’s voice, giving the record real emotional presence. It’s worth noting the earliest pressings were manufactured on Dynaflex vinyl, RCA’s thinner, lighter vinyl compound used to cut manufacturing costs in the early 70s — some collectors find these more prone to warping than heavier contemporary pressings, though sonically they’re still very well regarded. There are also several documented pressing variants from this era (including a “Superior Pressing” variant with slightly different labels), and original copies typically include an inner sleeve promoting other Motown releases. For a masterpiece originally treated somewhat unceremoniously by Motown at release (Berry Gordy reportedly disliked the record’s jazzy, socially conscious departure from formula), it’s a small irony that original pressings have since become genuinely prized by collectors and often go for surprisingly reasonable prices given the album’s stature and consistently strong sound quality.

It’s also worth flagging, for anyone shopping today rather than hunting an original: the 2022 50th Anniversary reissue, mastered by Kevin Gray, has been singled out by some longtime collectors and audiophile press as potentially the best-sounding version of the album currently available — some reviewers have gone as far as suggesting it may even supersede the original pressing in overall fidelity, thanks to a beautifully reproduced gatefold and a genuinely excellent modern cut. A Mobile Fidelity UD1S edition also exists for those chasing the absolute audiophile pinnacle. But a clean original 1971 Tamla pressing remains a wonderful, warm-sounding way to own this record, and for many purists it’s still the definitive way to experience it.

Side One

  1. What’s Going On — The title track and opening statement, one of the most important songs in American music history — a gentle, conversational plea for peace and understanding, built on a lush, jazz-inflected arrangement and Gaye’s famously layered, overlapping vocal takes. On a good original pressing, the warmth in the vocal presentation is genuinely special, and the bass sits beautifully close and present.
  2. What’s Happening Brother — A continuation of the album’s conversational, socially aware tone, addressing the disorientation of soldiers returning from Vietnam. The arrangement flows seamlessly from the title track, part of the album’s deliberate continuous-suite structure.
  3. Flyin’ High (In the Friendly Sky) — Melancholic and atmospheric, addressing addiction with genuine empathy rather than judgment — a beautifully arranged, emotionally complex piece.
  4. Save the Children — Expansive and orchestral, one of the album’s most ambitious compositions, blending spoken-word passages with soaring vocal melody.
  5. God Is Love — Brief and hymn-like, a gentle interlude that transitions naturally into the album’s most famous single.
  6. Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology) — A landmark environmental protest song disguised as a gorgeous, melodic soul number — one of the album’s most enduring tracks, and a genuine highlight of side one. The vocal layering and orchestral touches come through beautifully on a well-preserved original pressing.

Side Two

  1. Right On — Rhythmically adventurous and groove-driven, blending Latin-tinged percussion with jazz sensibilities — one of the album’s more musically exploratory tracks.
  2. Wholy Holy — A gorgeous, hymn-like ballad showcasing Gaye’s falsetto at its most tender and vulnerable — a genuine emotional high point of the whole record.
  3. Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler) — The album’s stark, powerful closer, addressing urban poverty and despair with an unflinching honesty that remains genuinely affecting over fifty years later. It’s a fitting, weighty conclusion to the album’s arc, and the dynamic tension in the arrangement rewards a pressing with good clarity and presence.

Final Verdict

What’s Going On is one of the most important and beautifully crafted albums ever made, and original 1971 Tamla pressings genuinely live up to the album’s reputation — warm, detailed, and full of the emotional presence that makes this record so enduringly powerful. It’s a rare case where a landmark album’s original vinyl pressing is both historically significant and widely praised as genuinely excellent-sounding, rather than something collectors have to make excuses for. Whether you track down an original copy or opt for the highly regarded 2022 Kevin Gray-mastered 50th Anniversary reissue, this is an essential album that rewards owning on vinyl as much as any record in the soul canon.

Buy this record at Boiler Room Records (opens in a new tab)

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.