Vinyl Review

Metallica : Death Magnetic : 2024

By ·

Metallica : Death Magnetic : 2024

Metallica – Death Magnetic (2024 Vinyl Reissue)

Originally released in 2008 as Metallica’s tenth studio album and widely viewed as a comeback after the divisive St. Anger, Death Magnetic explores themes of death, mortality, and rebirth across a return to the band’s classic thrash-influenced sound. This 2024 reissue presents the album as a 2LP set on 140g “Magnetic Silver” limited edition coloured vinyl, part of a wider ongoing campaign of Metallica catalogue reissues via UMR/Mercury/Blackened Recordings, pressed at Pallas in Germany.

The Pressing Here’s the honest truth about this one: no amount of pressing quality can fix what’s fundamentally wrong with Death Magnetic‘s mastering, and this 2024 edition doesn’t escape that reality. The album has long been one of the most notorious victims of the “loudness war” in modern rock — mastered with heavy brickwall limiting that famously produced audible clipping and distortion, particularly on Lars Ulrich’s drums, a flaw so well-documented that a fan-made “Guitar Hero” mix of the album (which used cleaner, uncompressed stems) is often cited by fans as sounding better than any official release. This reissue uses the same 2015 remaster previously issued on other formats, and several listeners who did direct comparisons report it’s essentially the same heavily compressed mix from 2008 — distortion on tracks like “The Day That Never Comes” and “The End of the Line” remains audible, and even Kevin Gray’s mastering work elsewhere in his career couldn’t meaningfully rescue this particular source material.

That said, on pure vinyl manufacturing terms, this is a genuinely clean pressing — flat, quiet, and free of surface noise, with the silver/grey colourway nicely matching the album’s artwork. Some listeners have actually found certain aspects of the vinyl cut preferable to the digital version, noting the instruments have more room to breathe and James Hetfield’s vocal sits slightly more forward in the mix than on the CD or streaming masters. So while the underlying mastering issues are baked into the source and can’t be undone, the pressing itself has been well-received as quiet and well-manufactured — it’s simply a case of a good pressing built on a fundamentally flawed master.

Side A

  1. That Was Just Your Life — A tense, riff-driven opener that reintroduces the band’s classic aggressive sound after the St. Anger era — energetic and immediate, though this is one of the tracks where the album’s compression issues are most audible in the drum mix.
  2. The End of the Line — Sprawling and riff-heavy, blending thrash energy with more melodic songwriting. Distortion in the mix has been specifically flagged by several listeners on this track.
  3. Broken, Beat & Scarred — Aggressive and anthemic, with a defiant, resilient lyrical theme that suits the album’s broader mortality-facing narrative.

Side B

  1. The Day That Never Comes — One of the album’s most structurally ambitious tracks, building from a slow, atmospheric intro into an explosive thrash finale. It’s also one of the most heavily criticized tracks on the album for audible drum distortion, a flaw that persists on this reissue.
  2. All Nightmare Long — Fast, aggressive, and one of the album’s most purely thrash-oriented tracks, harking back to the band’s earlier era.
  3. Cyanide — Groove-driven and riff-heavy, with a strong central hook.

Side C

  1. The Unforgiven III — The third installment in the band’s long-running “Unforgiven” song series, more melodic and reflective than much of the surrounding material, with orchestral touches adding scope.
  2. The Judas Kiss — Aggressive and riff-driven, with a menacing, confrontational energy.

Side D

  1. Suicide & Redemption — A lengthy instrumental epic, showcasing the band’s more progressive, extended songwriting ambitions.
  2. My Apocalypse — A fast, aggressive closer that brings the album’s themes to an explosive conclusion, ending the record with a burst of pure thrash energy.

Final Verdict

Death Magnetic remains a genuinely divisive entry in Metallica’s catalogue — a comeback in spirit and songwriting that was ultimately undermined by one of the most notorious mastering decisions in modern rock history. This 2024 reissue is a clean, quiet, well-manufactured pressing in purely physical terms, and the striking silver colourway is a nice touch for collectors. But no reissue, however well-pressed, can undo the brickwall compression baked into the source material — the same audible distortion and clipping that has plagued every prior release of this album remains present here. If you’re a completist or simply want the album on wax for the songs themselves, this is a perfectly serviceable pressing. If you’re hoping a new reissue might finally deliver the dynamic, properly mastered version of this record that fans have wanted for over 15 years, this unfortunately isn’t it.

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.