Nirvana : MTV Unplugged In New York : 2017

Nirvana – MTV Unplugged in New York (2017 Vinyl Reissue)
Recorded at Sony Studios in New York on November 18, 1993, and originally released in 1994, just months after Kurt Cobain’s death, MTV Unplugged in New York remains one of the most poignant live albums ever recorded — a stripped-down, acoustic reimagining of Nirvana’s catalogue alongside covers of Bowie, Lead Belly, and the Meat Puppets. This 2017 pressing is part of the “Back to Black” vinyl reissue series, presenting the original single-LP tracklist on 180g vinyl.
The Pressing This is genuinely one of the more confusing albums to shop for on vinyl, because MTV Unplugged‘s reissue history is a real minefield of differing mastering sources and pressing plants, and the 2017 Back to Black edition sits in a somewhat contested spot within that history. On the positive side, many buyers of this specific 2017 pressing report excellent results — warm, detailed, and quiet, with several listeners specifically praising the natural, harmonically rich reproduction of the acoustic guitars and Cobain’s vocal presence. One reviewer even noted being able to hear the subtle distortion character of a tube amp on “Oh Me,” a genuinely difficult thing to capture well on vinyl.
However, the wider Back to Black series (which also reissued this album in earlier pressing runs) has an inconsistent reputation among serious collectors, and it’s worth knowing where this fits. The gold standard for this album is widely considered to be the ORG Music pressing mastered by Bernie Grundman and pressed at Pallas in Germany — reviewers consistently praise this cut as sounding sublime, a real audiophile-grade treatment of an already superb original recording. By contrast, some Back to Black-era pressings from 2008 have been specifically called out by longtime collectors as poorly mastered and worth avoiding. The good news is that the specific 2017 pressing being reviewed here appears to be a later, improved repress within that same series, and reception to it specifically has generally been strong — but if you see a much older Back to Black copy going cheap, it’s worth checking which specific mastering source it uses before assuming quality parity with this one. A separate purple vinyl edition sold through Target also exists in two different cuts — one highly regarded (Bernie Grundman) and one considered less impressive — so it’s worth being specific about exactly which pressing you’re buying, as this album’s reissue landscape is genuinely more fragmented than most.
Side One
- About a Girl — A gentle, melodic opener that immediately reveals a different, more vulnerable side of the band than their electric material typically showcased.
- Come as You Are — Stripped of its familiar electric guitar tone, this reworking feels genuinely fresh, with Cobain’s vocal given real intimacy and space.
- Jesus Doesn’t Want Me for a Sunbeam — A haunting cover of the Vaselines, delivered with genuine tenderness.
- The Man Who Sold the World — A stunning cover of David Bowie, one of the performance’s most celebrated moments, and a genuinely transformative reinterpretation.
- Pennyroyal Tea — Raw and emotionally direct, translating surprisingly well to the acoustic arrangement.
- Dumb — Melodic and understated, showcasing the quieter, more melancholic side of Nirvana’s songwriting.
- Polly — Tense and unsettling even in its stripped-down form, retaining the original’s disturbing narrative power.
Side Two
- On a Plain — Melodic and driving even in acoustic form, a good showcase of the band’s underlying songcraft.
- Something in the Way — Quiet and haunting, one of the performance’s most emotionally weighty moments — worth noting this is also a track flagged on at least one problematic pressing for skipping issues, so it’s worth checking your copy carefully.
- Plateau — A Meat Puppets cover featuring Cris and Curt Kirkwood joining the band on stage, loose and warm.
- Oh, Me — Another Meat Puppets cover, showcasing genuinely lovely acoustic guitar tone that several reviewers have praised as a highlight of the whole album’s sound.
- Lake of Fire — The final Meat Puppets cover, dark and hypnotic, rounding out the trio of covers.
- All Apologies — Melancholic and resigned, one of the performance’s most quietly devastating moments.
- Where Did You Sleep Last Night — The performance’s legendary closer, a Lead Belly cover delivered with an almost unbearable emotional intensity that has become one of the most celebrated moments in the band’s entire discography. It’s a genuinely spine-tingling way to end the record, and a good pressing lets every raw vocal crack come through with full impact.
Final Verdict
MTV Unplugged in New York remains one of the most emotionally powerful live recordings ever committed to tape, and this 2017 Back to Black pressing generally delivers a warm, detailed, and satisfying listening experience by most accounts. That said, this is genuinely an album where pressing history matters more than usual — if ultimate fidelity is your priority, the ORG/Bernie Grundman pressing (pressed at Pallas) remains the pressing most serious collectors point to as definitive. For most listeners, though, this 2017 edition offers a genuinely rewarding way to experience the record without needing to chase down a pricier specialty pressing.