Pink Floyd : A Nice Pair : 1974

Pink Floyd – A Nice Pair (1974 Vinyl)
Released in late 1973/early 1974, A Nice Pair is a two-fer compilation combining Pink Floyd’s first two studio albums, The Piper at the Gates of Dawn (1967) and A Saucerful of Secrets (1968), repackaged into a single double-LP set after both original albums had drifted out of print in the wake of The Dark Side of the Moon‘s explosive success. It featured striking Hipgnosis gatefold artwork built around visual puns, and restored the single “Flaming” and the earlier compilation track “Bike” to their proper spots within Piper. The set has an interesting quirk depending on region: North American Capitol pressings substitute the original studio version of “Astronomy Domine” with the extended, live Ummagumma recording, running to over eight minutes — a genuinely different listening experience from the UK “Phang” pressing, which retains the original studio cut (some Canadian pressings also carry a different mix of “Jugband Blues”).
The Pressing Original pressings of A Nice Pair are consistently well-regarded by collectors, and reviewers repeatedly praise the sound as clean, warm, and nostalgic, with several specifically preferring the softness of these early pressings over more modern remasters, describing something genuinely “magical” and psychedelic about how the era-appropriate mastering suits this particular material. One collector specifically praised a Wally Traugott-cut US pressing as sounding excellent even with the substituted live “Astronomy Domine,” while another called the UK “Phang” pressing fantastic. Multiple reviewers note these pressings remain genuinely undervalued given the quality on offer — a good copy of both early Floyd albums for a modest price, with clean surfaces and only the expected light clicks and pops that come with an album now over fifty years old. It’s worth knowing this compilation has never been reissued on CD and only ever existed on vinyl, so an original pressing (in whichever regional variant you prefer) is the only way to own this particular version of the material, including that unique extended “Astronomy Domine” on North American copies.
Disc One: The Piper at the Gates of Dawn
Side One
- Astronomy Domine — A hypnotic, psychedelic opener built around Syd Barrett’s distinctive guitar work and haunting vocal delivery. On North American pressings, this is replaced by the extended live Ummagumma version, giving the album a dramatically different, more sprawling opening statement than UK listeners would have experienced.
- Lucifer Sam — Moody and rhythmically tight, one of Barrett’s most memorable early compositions, driven by a distinctive, twangy guitar riff.
- Matilda Mother — Whimsical and melodic, showcasing the band’s early flair for narrative-driven psychedelic songwriting.
- Flaming — Restored here to its proper album placement after being issued as a single, playful and gently trippy.
- Pow R. Toc H. — Experimental and rhythmically inventive, blending vocal effects with an improvisational structure.
- Take Up Thy Stethoscope and Walk — Aggressive and driving, one of the album’s harder-edged tracks, written by Roger Waters.
Side Two
- Interstellar Overdrive — A sprawling, exploratory instrumental and one of the definitive documents of the band’s early psychedelic improvisation, showcasing their willingness to stretch out well beyond conventional song structure.
- The Gnome — Charming and whimsical, one of Barrett’s most purely playful compositions.
- Chapter 24 — Atmospheric and meditative, drawing on the I Ching for its lyrical inspiration.
- The Scarecrow — Gentle and melodic, continuing the album’s fairy-tale-like lyrical sensibility.
- Bike — A genuinely charming, eccentric closer, restored here to the album proper after previously appearing only on the Relics compilation — one of Barrett’s most beloved and distinctively strange songs.
Disc Two: A Saucerful of Secrets
Side Three
- Let There Be More Light — A driving, more rock-oriented opener showing the band’s sound shifting following Barrett’s declining involvement.
- Remember a Day — Melodic and dreamy, one of Richard Wright’s compositional contributions.
- Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun — Atmospheric and hypnotic, one of Roger Waters’ most enduring early compositions and a genuine highlight of the album.
- Corporal Clegg — Satirical and driving, tackling anti-war themes with a distinctly British sensibility.
Side Four
- A Saucerful of Secrets — A sprawling, multi-part instrumental suite and the album’s ambitious centerpiece, showcasing the band’s evolving experimental and progressive tendencies well beyond their earlier psychedelic pop foundations.
- See-Saw — Gentle and melancholic, one of Wright’s more understated compositions.
- Jugband Blues — Syd Barrett’s haunting, fragmented final contribution to a Pink Floyd studio album, genuinely poignant given the context of his declining mental health and imminent departure from the band. Some Canadian pressings feature a distinct mix of this track, adding another layer of interest for collectors comparing regional variants.
Final Verdict
A Nice Pair offers a genuinely excellent way to own Pink Floyd’s essential, transitional early work in one attractive package, and original pressings hold up remarkably well — warm, clean, and possessed of a certain vintage character that many longtime fans prefer even to modern remasters. If you already own both individual albums, this compilation admittedly becomes somewhat redundant, but as a standalone artifact — particularly given the striking Hipgnosis artwork and the unique North American “Astronomy Domine” variant — it remains a worthwhile and still-affordable way to experience the band’s earliest, Barrett-era sound on genuinely lovely-sounding vintage vinyl.