Vinyl Review

Pink Floyd : Wish You Were Here : 2025

By ·

Pink Floyd : Wish You Were Here : 2025

Pink Floyd – Wish You Were Here (50th Anniversary Edition) (2025 Vinyl)

Released December 12, 2025, Wish You Were Here 50 celebrates the golden anniversary of Pink Floyd’s beloved 1975 album with a new remaster, a Dolby Atmos mix, early demos, alternate versions, and a Steven Wilson-remixed 1975 Los Angeles concert bootleg. The reissue proved a genuine commercial and cultural moment — it debuted as the UK’s Christmas Number One Album in 2025, marking the second time in the same year a Pink Floyd release topped the UK chart (following the Live at Pompeii soundtrack), a striking testament to how much enduring affection the band still commands fifty years on. Standalone vinyl editions include a striking yellow “flame” colorway alongside the standard black pressing.

The Pressing This is a genuinely mixed bag, and the core issue seems to be the new mastering itself rather than the physical manufacturing. Several longtime collectors who have closely tracked Pink Floyd’s various vinyl reissue eras have expressed real disappointment with this new cut, with more than one reviewer directly comparing it unfavorably to the well-loved 2016 Bernie Grundman remaster and an even more fondly regarded 2011 pressing — one longtime collector went so far as to say they “can’t listen to the 2025 cut” and that it “sounds plain wrong,” despite otherwise enjoying earlier reissues from the same mastering engineer. A recurring specific complaint is a struggling or reduced treble presence compared to prior pressings, with the 2025 cut described by at least one reviewer as “a slightly worse version of the 2016 BG remaster” in that regard.

That said, reactions aren’t uniformly negative, and there’s a genuine split in the data. Several buyers report their copy as clean, flat, and beautifully quiet straight out of the box, with balanced sound and no clicking or crackling — one reviewer went so far as to call their copy “the best copy of Wish You Were Here I have ever heard,” and another suggested that reported treble deficiencies might be more attributable to individual playback setups than the lacquer cut itself. The physical pressing quality (flatness, quietness, print quality) seems to be consistently well-regarded even among those critical of the tonal balance — the yellow vinyl colorway in particular has drawn praise for looking genuinely striking on a turntable. One minor complaint from a collector standpoint: unlike some previous anniversary editions, this standalone pressing doesn’t include the bonus inserts or postcard some fans expected given the 50th-anniversary billing. In short: this appears to be a case of a well-manufactured but debatably-mastered pressing — worth trying, but go in aware that dedicated collectors who’ve heard every prior reissue have genuinely split opinions on whether this new cut improves or slightly regresses from the well-loved 2016 version.

Side One

  1. Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts I-V) — A sprawling, emotionally powerful tribute to Syd Barrett, built on David Gilmour’s iconic four-note guitar motif. As with all pressings of this album, the extended synthesizer intro is a genuine test of a pressing’s soundstage and dynamic range.
  2. Welcome to the Machine — Dark and mechanical, addressing the dehumanizing nature of the music industry through layered synthesizers and eerie sound effects — critics have specifically praised how the keyboard textures on this track remain central to the song’s identity across every era of the album’s reissue history.
  3. Have a Cigar — Featuring guest vocalist Roy Harper, satirical and funky in its send-up of industry exploitation, again driven by keyboard work that reviewers consistently cite as essential to the track’s enduring power.

Side Two

  1. Wish You Were Here — The gorgeous title track, still described by critics as the emotional core of the album even fifty years on — its radio-static intro and intimate acoustic passage remain genuinely moving regardless of which specific mastering you’re hearing.
  2. Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts VI-IX) — The album’s extended, cathartic conclusion, bringing the Barrett tribute full circle.

Final Verdict

Wish You Were Here remains one of Pink Floyd’s most emotionally resonant achievements, and this 50th Anniversary edition arrives at a genuine cultural high point for the band, evidenced by its Christmas Number One chart placement. As a standalone vinyl pressing, though, this is a case where the underlying remaster has divided serious collectors — some hearing a genuine, if imperfect, evolution of the sound, others feeling it’s a step down from the widely beloved 2016 Bernie Grundman cut, particularly regarding treble presence. The physical manufacturing itself seems consistently well-regarded — flat, quiet, and attractive, especially in the yellow flame colorway. If you already own a well-loved 2011 or 2016 pressing, this may not be a clear upgrade; if you’re building your first collection or drawn specifically to the anniversary packaging and colorway, it remains a lovely and historically significant way to own this landmark album.

Buy this record at Boiler Room Records (opens in a new tab)

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.