Vinyl Review

Pink Floyd : Wish You Were Here –50– : 2025

By ·

Pink Floyd : Wish You Were Here –50– : 2025

Pink Floyd – Wish You Were Here 50 (Deluxe Box Set) (2025)

Released December 12, 2025, Wish You Were Here 50 is a lavish 50th anniversary deluxe box set marking the golden anniversary of Pink Floyd’s beloved 1975 album — and notably, the first Pink Floyd release to arrive since Sony fully acquired the band’s recorded catalog, meaning it could be produced on a much more timely schedule than past reissues (which had a history of years-long delays owing to disagreements between David Gilmour and Roger Waters). The box includes four vinyl LPs, two CDs, a Blu-ray disc, a hardcover book, a comic-book tour program reproduction, a Knebworth poster, and a Japanese replica 7″ single of “Have a Cigar”/”Welcome to the Machine.” The release proved a genuine cultural moment, debuting as the UK’s Christmas Number One Album.

What’s Inside

  • LP1: An exact reproduction of the original 1975 album, on clear vinyl.
  • LPs 2-3: A collection of rarities and alternate versions, including the previously-released (2011 Immersion box) alternate “Have a Cigar” with Roger Waters on lead vocals, the “Wish You Were Here” version featuring French jazz violinist Stéphane Grappelli, the instrumental “Wine Glasses” (from the abandoned Household Objects project, later reused in “Shine On You Crazy Diamond”‘s intro), a pedal steel guitar version of the title track, and “The Machine Song (Roger’s Demo),” an early home demo Waters originally brought to the band. The complete, uninterrupted “Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts 1-9)” is also included here.
  • LP4: A vinyl-exclusive disc featuring “Shine On You Crazy Diamond” and “You’ve Got to Be Crazy” recorded live at Wembley in 1974 — first released on CD as part of the 2011 Immersion box, now making their vinyl debut.
  • Blu-ray: The centerpiece of the whole set by most reviewer accounts, featuring the original album across four separate mixes — the original 1975 stereo mix, a 1975 quadraphonic mix, James Guthrie’s 2009 5.1 surround mix, and a brand-new Dolby Atmos mix by Guthrie and Joel Plante — plus video content including concert screen films and a Storm Thorgerson short film, and a genuinely significant inclusion: a previously unreleased live bootleg recorded April 26, 1975, at the Los Angeles Sports Arena by legendary taper Mike Millard, widely considered the best-quality surviving live recording of the band from this specific era.
  • Physical extras: A hardcover book with previously unseen photographs, a reproduction Floyd comic book, a folded Knebworth poster, and a Japanese-style 7″ single replica.

Assessment Critical reception has been warm but not uncritical, and it’s worth going in with a clear sense of what this box actually offers versus what longtime collectors may already own. Several reviewers have specifically noted this set draws heavily on material already released in the 2011 Wish You Were Here Experience and Immersion box sets — meaning the “new” content is genuinely limited to a handful of previously unreleased items: five new studio outtakes, plus the Dolby Atmos mix and the now-officially-released Millard live bootleg. One dedicated reviewer who directly compared this against the 2011 box called the new bonus studio material “interesting but not revelatory,” noting several alternate takes and demos included here were already available to anyone who owned the earlier deluxe edition. It’s also worth flagging a notable point of confusion some collectors have raised: rather than featuring a brand new 2025 remaster of the core album, the vinyl in this box appears to use the well-regarded 2016 mix — meaning if you’re expecting an entirely fresh mastering of the studio album itself within the vinyl portion of this box, that’s not quite what you’re getting (a separate standalone 2025 remaster does exist outside the box, but reception to that cut has been mixed, as some longtime collectors feel it’s a step down from the 2016 version).

On the positive side, the presentation itself is broadly praised as genuinely gorgeous — a sturdy road-case-style box, a well-produced hardcover book with strong photography, and the emotional impact of the clear vinyl pressing has resonated with more than one longtime collector on nostalgic grounds. The Blu-ray disc, and specifically the Millard live recording finally receiving an official release, has been singled out by multiple reviewers as the genuine highlight of the whole package — a legitimately significant historical document for serious fans. Some smaller complaints have surfaced too: one reviewer’s Knebworth poster arrived torn along its fold, and the same reviewer felt the overall memorabilia folder was comparatively thin next to what the 2011 Immersion box offered.

Final Verdict

Wish You Were Here 50 is a lovingly assembled, visually striking tribute to one of Pink Floyd’s most beloved albums, and the inclusion of the previously bootlegged Los Angeles 1975 concert recording alone makes it a genuinely worthwhile purchase for serious collectors and completists. However, this is very much a box built for people who don’t already own the 2011 Immersion set — much of the vinyl and CD content overlaps significantly with that earlier release, and the “new” material, while enjoyable, has been described by close listeners as more incremental than revelatory. If you already own the 2011 box and a well-regarded standalone pressing like the 2016 remaster, this may feel like a handsome but somewhat redundant purchase outside of the new Atmos mix and the Millard bootleg; if you’re building your collection from scratch or specifically want the definitive physical package for this album, it’s a genuinely rewarding, if imperfect, deluxe edition.

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.