Vinyl Review

Queen : A Kind Of Magic : 2020

By ·

Queen : A Kind Of Magic : 2020

Queen – A Kind of Magic (2020 Vinyl Reissue)

Released in 1986, A Kind of Magic is Queen’s twelfth studio album, built largely around music written for the Highlander film series and bolstered by the Live Aid-inspired anthem “One Vision.” It became the band’s biggest UK success up to that point, spending 63 weeks on the charts and topping the UK albums chart, though it fared less well in the US, peaking at only #45. This 2020 pressing (part of the ongoing “Studio Collection” reissue campaign) presents the album half-speed mastered by the acclaimed Bob Ludwig at Gateway Mastering, with the half-speed lacquers cut by Miles Showell at Abbey Road Studios, on 180g vinyl in a gatefold sleeve.

The Pressing This is a genuinely polarizing reissue, and it’s worth understanding both sides before buying. On the positive end, many listeners praise the half-speed mastering for its clarity and dynamics — one reviewer who compared it directly against a 1st UK pressing on the recommendation of a vinyl-focused YouTube reviewer found this pressing came out ahead, with genuinely impressive dynamic range. The broader “Studio Collection” box set (from which this standalone pressing derives) has also been reviewed very favorably in terms of manufacturing quality, with reviewers describing the vinyl as uncommonly quiet, warm, and pleasant to listen to.

However, a significant and recurring criticism specifically targets the A Kind of Magic entry in this reissue series more than most other Queen half-speed remasters. Multiple listeners have described this particular album’s mastering as excessively bright and over-compressed, with one detailed critique noting the guitars and synths become “uncomfortably ear-piercing,” the drums sound lifeless, and the overall punch and dynamic range feel squashed compared to how the record used to sound — the reviewer suspected the vinyl may have been cut directly from a digital master rather than analog tape. Another reviewer, while ultimately satisfied after adjusting their EQ, noted the album arguably needs a full remix rather than just a remaster, since even the original mix (specifically citing “Gimme the Prize”) suffers from unevenness that carries through to every version they’ve heard. That said, not every buyer has these complaints — several report a genuinely satisfying, clear listening experience, and one specifically praised the clarity of a transparent vinyl copy. In short: this is a reissue where your mileage may vary more than usual, and it’s worth going in aware that the underlying 2011 masters (or the specific half-speed cut of them) have drawn real criticism for excessive brightness and compression from a meaningful segment of listeners, alongside praise from others.

Side One

  1. One Vision — A soaring, anthemic opener inspired by the band’s Live Aid triumph, built on a driving rhythm and one of Freddie Mercury’s most inspirational vocal deliveries.
  2. A Kind of Magic — The title track and one of the album’s biggest hits, upbeat and hook-driven, tied directly to the Highlander soundtrack.
  3. One Year of Love — A romantic ballad that several critics have singled out as one of the album’s weaker moments — melodically pleasant but comparatively unmemorable.
  4. Pain Is So Close to Pleasure — Groove-driven and rhythmically distinctive, showing the band’s continued willingness to experiment stylistically.
  5. Friends Will Be Friends — A warm, uplifting mid-tempo anthem and one of the album’s most enduringly popular singles, showcasing the band’s knack for genuine emotional sincerity.

Side Two

  1. Who Wants to Live Forever — Widely regarded as one of the album’s true highlights, a haunting, orchestral ballad addressing mortality with real emotional weight — one of Queen’s most beloved and affecting compositions.
  2. Gimme the Prize (Kurgan’s Theme) — Aggressive and riff-heavy, directly tied to the Highlander film’s villain — also, per some reviewers, one of the tracks where the album’s underlying mix issues are most audible.
  3. Don’t Lose Your Head — Atmospheric and synth-driven, another Highlander-connected track that some critics find comparatively forgettable next to the album’s stronger material.
  4. Princes of the Universe — An aggressive, anthemic closer tied to the Highlander theme, bringing the album to an energetic conclusion.

Final Verdict

A Kind of Magic remains a genuinely uneven but ultimately rewarding entry in Queen’s catalogue — a “hit or miss” affair by even sympathetic critical accounts, with several stone-cold classics (“Who Wants to Live Forever,” “Friends Will Be Friends,” the title track) sitting alongside some comparatively weaker filler tracks tied to the Highlander soundtrack. This 2020 half-speed mastered reissue is a genuinely contested pressing among serious collectors: some find it a clear improvement over vintage pressings with excellent dynamics, while others feel it’s been mastered too bright and compressed, potentially inheriting flaws from an uneven original mix that no remaster alone can fully resolve. If you’re particularly sensitive to brightness or compression, it may be worth sampling before committing, or considering hunting down a well-regarded vintage UK pressing instead; if you already enjoy the “Studio Collection” series’ overall sound signature, this is likely to satisfy.

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.