Vinyl Review

Radiohead : OK Computer OKNOTOK 1997 2017 : 2017

By ·

Radiohead : OK Computer OKNOTOK 1997 2017 : 2017

Radiohead – OK Computer OKNOTOK 1997 2017 (2017 Vinyl)

Released June 23, 2017, on XL Recordings — coinciding with the 20th anniversary of the original album — OKNOTOKexpands OK Computer into a 23-track collection: the original twelve-track album, eight B-sides, and three previously unreleased tracks (“I Promise,” “Lift,” and “Man of War”), all newly remastered from the original analog tapes. Housed across three LPs in a triple-pocket gatefold sleeve, it was initially limited to 7,000 copies for indie record stores before an unconfirmed extension to roughly 10,000 due to overwhelming pre-order demand. Critical reception was strongly positive, with reviewers noting the three “lost” tracks meaningfully enrich understanding of the original album’s creative process, even if the reissue’s main justification for casual listeners is simply the excuse to revisit a genuine masterpiece.

The Pressing This is a genuinely inconsistent release from a manufacturing standpoint, and it’s worth knowing there are actually two distinct pressings of this same title circulating, with notably different reputations. The original 2017 blue vinyl pressing (Optimal Media, limited indie-exclusive run) has drawn mixed but generally more positive reviews — several listeners describe it as dead quiet, warm, and detailed, with one reviewer specifically noting how shocked they were at how quiet all three LPs sounded. However, a meaningful number of buyers also report distortion, pops, and clicks even after thorough cleaning, with more than one reviewer suspecting genuine pressing defects rather than playback issues, given consistent results across multiple turntables and cartridges.

A separate, later black vinyl pressing (manufactured in the Czech Republic, distinct from the original Optimal pressing) has been repeatedly and specifically praised by reviewers as sounding meaningfully better than the earlier version — cleaner, more spacious, with better-defined bass and crystal-clear vocals and guitars, free of the “wooly” or muffled low end some reported on the initial release. Multiple reviewers who compared both directly recommend seeking out this later pressing and avoiding an earlier “2016 XL reissue” of the standalone album, which one described as sounding dull and missing the “essence” of the record. A separate deluxe box set edition (including a cassette and hardcover art books) has drawn its own mixed reception — while the packaging is universally praised as premium, several reviewers found the actual album mastering muffled and compressed, though the B-sides disc within that same box was singled out as sounding spectacular by comparison. In short: this is a title where the specific pressing you get matters quite a bit, and it’s worth confirming you’re getting the more recent, better-regarded Czech-manufactured pressing rather than an earlier version if sound quality is your priority.

Original Album (Discs I & II)

  1. Airbag — A tense, atmospheric opener built on a distinctive, glitchy drum loop and driving guitar work — a genuinely thrilling statement of purpose for the album’s paranoid, technology-anxious themes.
  2. Paranoid Android — A sprawling, multi-part epic blending acoustic tenderness with explosive guitar aggression — one of the most ambitious and beloved singles in the band’s catalogue.
  3. Subterranean Homesick Alien — Dreamy and atmospheric, blending Thom Yorke’s ethereal vocal with hypnotic, textured production.
  4. Exit Music (For a Film) — Hauntingly minimal and building to a genuinely devastating climax, one of the album’s most emotionally powerful tracks.
  5. Let Down — Melodic and cathartic, one of the album’s most beloved songs, blending intricate guitar interplay with an anthemic, cascading chorus.
  6. Karma Police — Melancholic and melodically direct, one of the album’s most accessible and enduringly popular singles.
  7. Fitter Happier — A brief, unsettling spoken-word interlude delivered via computerized voice, encapsulating the album’s central anxieties about modern alienation.
  8. Electioneering — Aggressive and politically pointed, one of the album’s harder-edged rock moments.
  9. Climbing Up the Walls — Genuinely unsettling and atmospheric, blending distorted textures with a creeping sense of dread.
  10. No Surprises — Gentle and melodic on the surface, masking deeply despairing lyrics — one of the album’s most beloved and paradoxically soothing tracks.
  11. Lucky — Atmospheric and hopeful, building to a soaring, cathartic conclusion.
  12. The Tourist — A slow, reflective closer, bringing the album’s frenetic energy to a contemplative, unhurried resolution.

Bonus Discs: B-Sides and Unreleased Tracks

Additional tracks include “Palo Alto,” “Meeting in the Aisle,” “Polyethylene (Parts 1 & 2),” “Pearly,” “A Reminder,” “Melatonin,” “Lull,” and the three genuine highlights for longtime fans: “I Promise” (melodic and tender, long considered one of the band’s great unreleased songs), “Lift” (upbeat and unusually optimistic for this era of the band), and “Man of War” (a soaring, dramatic epic originally intended for a James Bond film before ultimately going unused) — all three widely praised by critics as genuinely strong additions that enrich rather than dilute the original album’s legacy.

Final Verdict

OK Computer remains one of the most important and influential albums ever recorded, and OKNOTOK is a genuinely worthwhile way to revisit it, both for the newly remastered original album and for three long-rumored unreleased tracks that critics have consistently praised as legitimate additions to the Radiohead canon. As a pressing, though, this release requires some care in sourcing — the specific edition matters more than usual, with the later Czech-manufactured black vinyl pressing consistently outperforming the original 2017 blue vinyl release in reported sound quality, and the deluxe box set edition drawing more mixed reviews on its core album mastering despite excellent packaging. For serious Radiohead fans, this remains an essential purchase; just do a little homework on which specific pressing variant you’re buying before committing.

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.