Vinyl Review

Talk Talk : It’s My Life : 2024

By ·

Talk Talk : It’s My Life : 2024

Talk Talk – It’s My Life (2024 40th Anniversary Vinyl Reissue)

Originally released January 1984 on EMI, It’s My Life is Talk Talk’s second studio album — the record where producer and multi-instrumentalist Tim Friese-Greene joined the band and helped transform their early new-romantic sound into something more sophisticated, home to the title track, “Such a Shame,” and “Dum Dum Girl.” This 2024 pressing, released October 4 on Parlophone to mark the album’s 40th anniversary, was overseen by Talk Talk drummer Lee Harris and Mark Hollis’s son Charlie, presenting the album as a half-speed remaster with restoration work by Cally, remastering by Phill Brown, and lacquer cutting attributed to Matt Colton.

The Pressing This is a genuinely contentious reissue, and the specific problems reported are consistent enough across multiple independent listeners to warrant real caution. The core issue appears to be mastering-related rather than manufacturing defects: several reviewers report the cut is unusually “hot,” loud, and in places audibly overdriven, with one detailed technical review — from a listener with high-end playback gear (a quality moving-coil cartridge and adjustable phono preamp) — describing the pressing as louder than 90% of their entire collection, and specifically identifying audible clipping in spots. That same reviewer noted this tendency has shown up on other releases cut by the same engineer, Matt Colton, and expressed concern about how his other forthcoming Talk Talk work might fare. Another reviewer described the distortion as severe enough to render the final track of side one “unlistenable,” even after a thorough ultrasonic cleaning — ruling out surface dirt as the cause and pointing more firmly toward the mastering itself. A few more forgiving listeners noted the record initially sounds decent but becomes more fatiguing “the more you listen,” while one dissenting voice found their copy merely “a little hard recorded” rather than genuinely distorted, suggesting some copy-to-copy or system-dependent variance exists even within this specific pressing run.

For context, it’s worth knowing this album has a famously fraught pressing history across all its eras — even genuine 1984 UK originals are notoriously difficult to find playing cleanly, with one dedicated collector describing years of trying and ultimately giving up on finding a clean-playing UK original, attributing the issue to the shallow-cut DMM grooves used at the time. A 2020 Rhino reissue (as part of the “Start Your Ear Off Right” campaign) fared considerably better by most accounts — described by multiple reviewers as thick, flat, and excellent-sounding, provided you got a copy with the “Made in Germany” manufacturing sticker, since some Rhino pressings from that era were reportedly flat or noisy depending on plant. If you’re specifically chasing a great-sounding vinyl copy of this album and are wary of this 2024 half-speed edition’s reported mastering issues, that 2020 Rhino purple vinyl pressing may be a safer, better-regarded alternative.

Side One

  1. Dum Dum Girl — An upbeat, hook-driven opener showcasing the band’s newly sophisticated production style under Tim Friese-Greene’s guidance.
  2. Such a Shame — One of the album’s standout singles, atmospheric and melodically rich, blending mainstream pop sensibility with more ambitious arrangement choices.
  3. Renée — Reflective and melodic, continuing the album’s blend of polished synth-pop with genuine emotional depth.
  4. It’s My Life — The title track and one of the band’s most enduring singles, later famously covered by No Doubt — a genuinely gorgeous, atmospheric pop song built on Mark Hollis’s distinctive vocal delivery.

Side Two

  1. Tomorrow Started — Atmospheric and melodically confident, showing the band’s continued evolution beyond straightforward new wave.
  2. Does Caroline Know? — Upbeat and hook-driven, one of the album’s more immediate pop moments.
  3. Call in the Night Boy — Melodic and reflective, continuing the album’s sophisticated, textured sound.
  4. The Last Time — A fitting, atmospheric closer, bringing the album’s stylistic evolution to a satisfying conclusion and hinting at the more ambitious, experimental direction the band would pursue on subsequent albums.

Final Verdict

It’s My Life remains a genuinely important transitional album in Talk Talk’s evolution — the moment their sound began moving toward the more textured, ambitious territory that would eventually lead to The Colour of Spring and beyond. Unfortunately, this specific 2024 40th anniversary half-speed reissue has drawn a meaningful and consistent set of complaints about overdriven, hot mastering with audible clipping in places — problems that appear to stem from the cutting choices rather than pressing defects, meaning cleaning your copy likely won’t resolve the issue if you encounter it. Given the album’s famously difficult pressing history across every era, and the specific concerns raised about this particular reissue, it may be worth considering the well-regarded 2020 Rhino purple vinyl pressing instead if pristine, dynamically clean sound is your priority — though if you already own this 2024 edition and it plays free of audible distortion, several listeners have found it perfectly enjoyable.

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.