Vinyl Review

The Beatles : Abbey Road : 2019

By ·

The Beatles : Abbey Road : 2019

The Beatles – Abbey Road: 50th Anniversary Edition (2019 Vinyl)

Released September 27, 2019, on Apple/Capitol/UMe, this 50th anniversary reissue presents the Beatles’ final recorded album (originally released 1969) with a brand-new stereo remix by Giles Martin — son of original producer George Martin — and engineer Sam Okell, working directly from the original multi-track tapes. Released in multiple formats including a standalone 180g LP, a 3LP vinyl box, and the deluxe Super Deluxe edition featuring 23 bonus outtakes and demos, half-speed lacquers were cut by Miles Showell, following the same acclaimed anniversary treatment previously given to Sgt. Pepper (2017) and the White Album (2018).

The Pressing This is a genuinely fascinating and divisive reissue, with expert reviewers splitting quite sharply on whether the new remix and mastering represent a genuine improvement over vintage originals. Some listeners are unreservedly enthusiastic — one Discogs reviewer called it “an outstanding pressing” and one of the best-sounding records in their entire collection, remaining genuinely affordable given the quality on offer. A detailed audiophile review concluded that, absent a full analog remaster of the original mix released on high-quality vinyl, this 50th Anniversary edition represents “arguably the best sounding option at present,” praising Giles Martin’s work for delivering additional clarity without straying radically from the album’s original sound design and intent.

However, more critical and technically detailed reviews complicate that picture considerably. One in-depth comparison against an original US pressing found the reissue’s top-end cymbal sound curiously reserved throughout the album (though present in full on the bonus material), and specifically noted Ringo’s kick drum on “Sun King” sounded both quieter and lacking the distinctive “pop” of the original — concluding the reissue improves on the original in some ways (notably a more robust bottom end) while diminishing it in others, particularly in terms of raw excitement and the airy, atmospheric mystery of certain passages (the outdoor cricket sound effects, for instance, feel less immersive on the reissue). Another reviewer who owns a genuinely excellent original US Apple pressing went further, finding the new remix so close to the original that they questioned the entire point of remixing it, and ultimately concluded the 50th anniversary vinyl sounded “noticeably inferior” to their vintage original — a striking claim given how much technical care and reverence went into the remix process. A more measured assessment found the new stereo mix simply offers “better depth and clarity” compared to the 2009 remaster when doing direct A/B comparisons on CD, suggesting the improvements may register more clearly against modern digital remasters than against a truly excellent vintage vinyl pressing.

The Super Deluxe edition’s packaging and presentation have been almost universally praised regardless of the sonic debate — reviewers describe the disc sleeves faithfully reproducing original UK edition artwork, a beautifully constructed hardback book with previously unseen photographs from the iconic cover photoshoot, and genuinely revelatory bonus material, including 23 outtakes and demos that Rolling Stone specifically praised for capturing the band “in the zone,” playful and focused during their final creative collaboration.

Side One

  1. Come Together — A hypnotic, bass-driven opener with an instantly recognizable groove — one of the album’s most enduring and frequently covered tracks.
  2. Something — George Harrison’s gorgeous, much-lauded love song, widely regarded as one of the finest ballads in the band’s entire catalogue.
  3. Maxwell’s Silver Hammer — Playful and macabre, one of the album’s more divisive tracks in terms of tone, though musically confident.
  4. Oh! Darling — A raw, soulful vocal showcase for McCartney, and specifically one of the tracks Giles Martin highlighted in promoting this remix, with a “Take 4” alternate version included in the bonus material.
  5. Octopus’s Garden — Ringo Starr’s charming, whimsical contribution, gentle and melodically appealing.
  6. I Want You (She’s So Heavy) — A sprawling, hypnotic epic building to a genuinely overwhelming climax, showcasing the band’s willingness to experiment with extended, repetitive structures.

Side Two

  1. Here Comes the Sun — Another Harrison masterpiece and one of the most beloved songs in the Beatles’ catalogue, warm and optimistic.
  2. Because — A gorgeous, intricately harmonized ballad, showcasing the band’s vocal blend at its most sophisticated.

9-17. The Medley (“You Never Give Me Your Money,” “Sun King,” “Mean Mr. Mustard,” “Polythene Pam,” “She Came in Through the Bathroom Window,” “Golden Slumbers,” “Carry That Weight,” “The End,” “Her Majesty”) — The album’s towering, side-length suite, tying together fragments and full songs into one of the most celebrated extended compositions in rock history, culminating in “The End”‘s legendary three-way guitar solo trade-off between McCartney, Harrison, and Lennon, recorded live on the studio floor — a moment the 2019 remix specifically brings out with newfound clarity, according to multiple reviewers.

Final Verdict

Abbey Road remains one of the most celebrated and joyous final statements in rock history, and this 50th anniversary edition offers a respectful, technically accomplished new perspective on the album — genuinely excellent as a standalone listening experience, and packaged (particularly in the Super Deluxe edition) with real care and historical value through its bonus outtakes and lavish book. Whether it actually improves on a genuinely excellent vintage original pressing is a matter of real debate among serious collectors: some hear meaningful gains in clarity and depth, while others — including listeners with exceptional original US pressings for comparison — find the new mix curiously restrained in places, sacrificing some of the original’s raw excitement and atmospheric character in exchange for a more polished, bottom-heavy presentation. If you don’t already own a great vintage pressing, this is a wonderful and easy way to experience the album; if you do, it’s worth sampling before assuming it’s an automatic upgrade.

Buy this record at Boiler Room Records (opens in a new tab)

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.