Vinyl Review

The Beatles : Yellow Submarine Songtrack

By ·

The Beatles : Yellow Submarine Songtrack

The Beatles – Yellow Submarine Songtrack (1999 Vinyl)

Released September 1999 on Apple/EMI to coincide with the theatrical re-release of the 1968 animated film Yellow Submarine, this compilation replaces George Martin’s orchestral film score from the original 1969 album with a complete collection of all Beatles songs featured in the movie — including several tracks not present on that earlier release. Crucially, every track here was entirely remixed by Peter Cobbin at Abbey Road Studios directly from the original multitrack tapes, something that hadn’t been attempted for the standard Beatles catalogue since the original late-80s CD releases. Issued on both black and yellow vinyl (with identical sleeve artwork across both variants), this album is now widely regarded as a genuine landmark in the Beatles’ remastering history — the direct forerunner to the celebrated 2009 stereo and 2014 mono remaster campaigns.

The Pressing This is one of the most consistently and enthusiastically praised Beatles vinyl releases in the entire catalogue, and reviewer consensus borders on unanimous. Multiple listeners describe it as one of the best-sounding, if not the best-sounding, Beatles compilation ever pressed — dead silent vinyl, rich bass, wide soundstage, and genuinely superior instrument separation compared to the original stereo mixes these songs had circulated in for decades. One especially enthusiastic review called Peter Cobbin’s mix “masterful,” describing it as the best the Beatles have ever sounded in stereo, and specifically credited this release as a genuine steal if found around $30. Another reviewer noted the definitive stereo mix of “Only a Northern Song” appears here for the first time — a track previously only available in true stereo on this specific release, since it was originally a mono-only recording repurposed with genuine stereo separation for this project.

There is a genuine minority dissenting view worth noting: at least one reviewer felt the mixes could sound overly “clinical,” describing them as anemic in places and lacking the raw character of a proper rock record mastering, though even that same reviewer conceded certain vocals sound genuinely breathtaking and specifically praised the “Only a Northern Song” mix as a major improvement. Another detailed reviewer, while calling the vinyl “fantastic sounding” overall, specifically wished for more high-frequency shimmer on cymbals and a bit more edge on the guitars, feeling the bass and drum placement (dead center in the mix) was exactly right but that the top end held back slightly. Later reissues (a 2004/2005 Japanese pressing and a subsequent 2024 repress) have continued to draw strong praise, with the 2024 edition specifically described as an “heir” to the celebrated 2014 mono vinyl series and praised for dead-silent, flat playback.

Side One

  1. Yellow Submarine — The title track, a genuinely joyous singalong classic given fresh clarity and separation in this remix.
  2. Hey Bulldog — A driving, riff-heavy deep cut that many fans consider one of the standout inclusions unique to this collection, benefiting enormously from the remix’s improved punch and detail.
  3. Eleanor Rigby — One of the Beatles’ most celebrated orchestral compositions, rendered here with striking new clarity — though some listeners feel later remasters (2015, 2022) have since bettered even this excellent version.
  4. Love You To — George Harrison’s Indian classical-influenced composition, given genuine sonic depth in this remix.
  5. All Together Now — A charming, singalong-style track well suited to the film’s whimsical tone.
  6. Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds — Dreamlike and psychedelic, benefiting from the remix’s improved instrumental separation.
  7. Think for Yourself — Another Harrison composition, showcasing distinctive fuzz-bass work brought out with newfound presence.

Side Two

  1. Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band — The explosive title track excerpt, energetic and theatrical.
  2. With a Little Help from My Friends — Ringo Starr’s beloved lead vocal turn, warm and inviting.
  3. Baby You’re a Rich Man — Repeatedly singled out by reviewers as a genuine highlight of this remix, sounding better here than in any prior stereo release.
  4. Only a Northern Song — A genuinely historic inclusion, marked by reviewers as the definitive way to hear this track — the first true stereo mix ever produced, a genuine landmark improvement over decades of inferior prior versions.
  5. All You Need Is Love — The band’s anthemic message of unity, given renewed clarity and presence.
  6. When I’m Sixty-Four — Charming and nostalgic, benefiting from the remix’s improved vocal centering.
  7. Nowhere Man — Specifically praised by multiple reviewers as one of the standout highlights of the entire album in this new mix.
  8. It’s All Too Much — A sprawling, psychedelic epic closing the album, praised by fans as never having sounded better than on this specific release.

Final Verdict

Yellow Submarine Songtrack stands as one of the most quietly important and consistently excellent Beatles releases in the entire catalogue — not because of the songs themselves (all previously available elsewhere), but because Peter Cobbin’s pioneering remix work here directly paved the way for the celebrated remastering campaigns that followed in 2009 and 2014. Reviewers across nearly every pressing era describe this album as sounding genuinely phenomenal — clear, dynamic, and revelatory compared to the decades-old stereo mixes these songs had circulated in previously. Whether you track down an original 1999 yellow or black vinyl pressing, a 2004/2005 reissue, or the well-regarded 2024 repress, this remains an essential and consistently well-executed addition to any serious Beatles vinyl collection.

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.