Various : High Fidelity (Original Soundtrack) : 2024

Various Artists – High Fidelity (Original Soundtrack) (2024 Vinyl Reissue)
Originally released March 2000 on Hollywood Records to accompany the John Cusack film adaptation of Nick Hornby’s beloved novel about a record-store-owning music obsessive, this soundtrack has long been considered one of the finest movie soundtracks built around a genuinely great record collection — spanning garage rock, British Invasion, and soul touchstones. This 2024 pressing, released for Record Store Day Black Friday, brings the album back to vinyl in a limited “Blue Jay” colorway, marking one of several reissues the soundtrack has received since its original release (following a well-regarded 15th Anniversary edition back in 2016).
The Pressing This is a genuinely well-regarded reissue overall, though reviewer accounts reveal an interesting quirk worth knowing about. Several listeners describe their copies as perfectly solid, flat blue vinyl with zero background noise across both records, with one reviewer specifically calling it “a proper reissue” and enthusiastically recommending it to anyone who loves the film. Another buyer, while more measured, called the pressing “not spectacular, but really solid” and notably above average for a GZ Media pressing (a plant that carries a mixed reputation among vinyl collectors), reporting mostly quiet playback.
A more detailed and critical review flagged a genuinely interesting inconsistency: the first LP sounded fairly brickwalled, apparently sourced from a digital master, with noticeably bad sibilance specifically on Sheila Nicholls’ “Fallen for You” — but moving on to the second LP, that same reviewer found what felt like an entirely different, better-sourced pressing, speculating this might reflect a GZ Media quirk where the first disc benefits from a wet clean before playing its best. That reviewer still landed on being “pretty happy” overall with a click/pop-free, flat pressing despite the source-quality inconsistency between discs. It’s also worth knowing this reissue reflects some licensing changes from the original 2000 release — several tracks originally included (notably by The Jam and Barry White) couldn’t be cleared for this reissue and are only findable on the increasingly hard-to-find original UK pressing, so if those specific songs matter to you, it’s worth checking the exact tracklist before buying. The package itself has been praised for its attention to detail, with a subtle “ringwear” aging effect on the cover art and a vintage-styled image of the film’s record store on the reverse — a nice touch given the film’s own deep reverence for vinyl culture (and a nod to how the US soundtrack cover itself references the Beatles’ A Hard Day’s Night US LP artwork).
Side A
- You’re Gonna Miss Me (The 13th Floor Elevators) — A blistering, psychedelic garage-rock classic and one of the most electrifying openers any soundtrack compilation could ask for, setting an appropriately obsessive, record-collector energy right from the start.
- Everybody’s Gonna Be Happy (The Kinks) — Upbeat and melodically direct, representing the British Invasion foundation of Rob’s musical taste.
- I’m Wrong About Everything (John Wesley Harding) — Wry and self-deprecating, thematically perfect for a film about a man whose romantic and musical opinions are constantly being challenged.
- Oh! Sweet Nuthin’ (The Velvet Underground) — A gorgeous, understated deep cut showcasing the band’s more tender, melodic side — a genuine testament to the soundtrack’s crate-digging sensibility.
Side B
- Dry the Rain (The Beta Band) — Famously used in the film’s own in-story record store scene, where Rob’s employees play it for a skeptical customer — a genuinely meta moment that helped introduce a whole generation of listeners to the band.
- Let’s Get It On (Barry Jive and His Uptown Five, feat. Jack Black) — A gleefully over-the-top cover performed in-character by Jack Black’s Barry, comedic and surprisingly committed — one of the soundtrack’s most memorable and beloved inclusions.
- Shakin’ All Over (The Guess Who) — Driving and confident, injecting real rock energy into the compilation’s midsection.
Side C
- A Salty Dog (Procol Harum) — Atmospheric and melodically ambitious, showcasing a more progressive, orchestral rock sensibility within the soundtrack’s broader classic rock foundation.
- Seemed Like a Good Idea at the Time (Stereolab) — Melodic and slightly experimental, representing the more contemporary end of the soundtrack’s stylistic range.
- Marie (Love) — A genuine deep cut for serious record collectors, tender and melodically rich, tying the soundtrack to one of the era’s most influential and underappreciated bands.
Side D
- Most of the Time (Bob Dylan) — Reflective and emotionally weighted, one of Dylan’s most quietly devastating compositions, fitting the film’s themes of romantic reflection and regret.
- Turnstyles and Junkpiles (Smog) — Atmospheric and lo-fi, offering a genuinely underground, indie-rock counterpoint to the soundtrack’s more classic selections.
Final Verdict
High Fidelity remains one of the most beloved and carefully curated movie soundtracks ever assembled, and it’s genuinely fitting that a film so obsessed with vinyl culture continues to receive thoughtful vinyl reissue treatment. This 2024 Blue Jay pressing is a generally well-regarded release — the majority of listeners report clean, quiet playback, though it’s worth being aware of the reported inconsistency between the two included LPs (with the first disc potentially benefiting from a wet clean before it plays at its best) and the fact that a couple of tracks from the original 2000 release didn’t survive into this edition due to licensing issues. For fans of the film, the soundtrack itself remains genuinely excellent — a true crate-digger’s compilation that holds up as well as any soundtrack of its era — and this reissue offers a lovingly packaged, mostly satisfying way to own it on wax.