Vinyl Review

Fontaines D.C. — Romance (Vinyl, 2024, XL Recordings)

By ·

Fontaines D.C. — Romance (Vinyl, 2024, XL Recordings)

Summary

Romance is the sound of a band deliberately stepping outside the box they built for themselves. Where Dogrel and A Hero’s Death were rooted in a very specific, very Dublin kind of rock, this record — Fontaines D.C.’s first for XL Recordings — feels wider, stranger, and more willing to let synths and atmosphere do the talking. On vinyl it’s an 11-track, single-LP release, and it’s the kind of record that rewards the format: the pacing between the loud tracks and the quiet ones is clearly built for sides, not shuffle.

Where It Was Recorded, Mastered & Pressed

The bulk of the album was tracked at La Frette Studios just outside Paris in November 2023, with one track (“Here’s the Thing”) done at The Church Studios in London — strings were handled separately at Studio Orbb. James Ford produced. Mastering was done at Metropolis Mastering in London by Matt Colton, who also cut the lacquers. The main pressing run was manufactured by Optimal Media in Germany (regional variants — like the Australian pressing — were handled by other plants, Program Records in Thornbury for that market), on 180-gram vinyl in a range of colorways depending on which edition you picked up.

The Pressing

This is a genuinely well-mastered rock record for a vinyl era that doesn’t always treat guitar bands kindly. Colton’s master keeps real dynamic range in the drums instead of flattening everything into a wall — you can hear Tom Coll’s kit breathe even on the more maximalist tracks like “Starburster.” The low end on “Death Kink” has actual weight instead of turning to mush, and the quieter, string-laden tracks come through with a warmth that a lot of modern rock pressings lose in the mastering. Copies vary a little by pressing plant and colorway, as they always do with multiple regional runs, but the standard black and the widely available colored variants are consistently reported as flat, quiet, and well-centered.

Track-by-Track

1. Romance — Opening on something this hushed and eerie instead of a big statement track is such a confident choice. It sets a tone of unease that the rest of the record keeps circling back to.

2. Starburster — That gasping, stuttering rhythm still catches me off guard no matter how many times I’ve heard it. It’s the sound of a band actively refusing to repeat themselves.

3. Here’s the Thing — Jangly and almost playful after the tension of the opening two tracks — it feels like exhaling.

4. Desire — There’s a real menace under the surface of this one. Grian’s vocal delivery does a lot of the work here, more sneer than shout.

5. In the Modern World — This is the one that got me the most on first listen — there’s a longing in it that feels genuinely new for this band, less clenched fist, more open hand.

6. Bug — Compact and wiry, a reminder that they can still do the taut, coiled thing when they want to.

7. Motorcycle Boy — Dreamy in a way that still surprises me from this band — it drifts instead of driving forward, and I mean that as a compliment.

8. Sundowner — One of the more emotionally exposed moments on the record. It doesn’t hide behind atmosphere the way some of the other tracks do.

9. Horseness Is the Whatness — The title alone tells you they’re having fun with language again, and the track itself feels loose and literary in a way that rewards a lyric sheet.

10. Death Kink — Genuinely one of the heaviest things they’ve put to tape — the weight in the low end on the vinyl pressing really does this one justice.

11. Favourite — Closing on something this tender and open-hearted, after everything that came before, hits harder than a big finale would have. It’s the sound of the album finally letting its guard down completely.

Final Thought

Romance is a record about a band refusing to stay still, and the vinyl pressing treats that ambition seriously — nothing here sounds compressed into safety. If Skinty Fia was Fontaines D.C. perfecting their sound, this is them actively risking it, and hearing that risk on a well-mastered piece of vinyl, side by side, makes the transformation land even harder than it does streaming track by track.

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.