HMV (Poole branch, Dorset))

HMV Poole: Records as Product, Not Passion
Walking into HMV after spending time in the independents around Dorset is a genuinely different experience, and not entirely in a good way. It’s big, it’s bright, it’s laid out with all the polish you’d expect from a chain — but that polish is exactly what’s missing something. There’s no sense of anyone behind the counter who’s actually chosen what’s on the shelves because they love it; it’s stock, arranged efficiently, there to move units rather than reflect anyone’s taste.
That’s the difference that hits you almost immediately. In a proper independent, you can usually feel a person behind the selection — someone who’s decided this is worth stocking and that isn’t, who can tell you something about a pressing because they actually care. HMV doesn’t have that, and it’s not really trying to. The vinyl here reads as product in the most literal sense: chart-friendly reissues, popular soundtracks, whatever’s guaranteed to sell, all facing out under the same clean lighting as everything else in the shop. It’s merchandising, not curation.
To be fair, it’s not without its uses. If you’re after a straightforward repressing of something well-known, HMV will probably have it, and you won’t need to dig for it — everything’s alphabetised, easy to find, no crate-digging required. There’s a convenience to that I won’t pretend doesn’t exist. But convenience and character aren’t the same thing, and HMV has plenty of the former and not much of the latter.
What it really feels like, more than anything, is a big chain doing what big chains do — extracting as much money as possible from customers who might not know or care about the difference, rather than fostering any real relationship with the music or the people buying it. Nothing about the visit made me feel like part of a community the way the independents do; it felt transactional in a way record shopping shouldn’t.
Verdict: Fine for a straightforward repressing in a pinch, but HMV Poole is a big chain store through and through — all product, no personality, and no reason to choose it over somewhere that actually cares what it sells.