Vinyl Review

Sanctuary — Evanescence (2LP, 2026)

By ·

Sanctuary — Evanescence (2LP, 2026)

I picked this one up the way I pick most things up these days — not off a link at Amazon, but from a crate, in a shop that smells like dust and old cardboard, the kind of place where the bloke behind the counter knows you by the records you’ve bought before. There’s something fitting about that, actually, because Evanescence has always been a “found in a crate” kind of band for me. Fallen was the album that got passed around at Uni, on a burned CD before any of us had proper taste. Twenty-odd years on, here I am, cleaning the dust off a gatefold sleeve with Sanctuary stamped across it in that same gothic, slightly overwrought type they’ve always used, and it still gives me a little jolt.

This is Evanescence’s sixth studio record, and their first in five years. Amy Lee has said it took over three years to make, and you can feel that weight in every groove — this isn’t a quick cash-in reunion record, it’s a proper, heavy, deliberate piece of work. Bringing in Zakk Cervini and Jordan Fish alongside longtime collaborator Nick Raskulinecz was a smart move; it drags the band’s sound somewhere a bit more modern without sabotaging the gothic-orchestral DNA that made them who they are. The double vinyl pressing gives the whole thing room to breathe — four sides, proper dynamic range, the kind of low end that a phone speaker will never do justice to.

Dropping the needle on side A for the first time, before I’d even read a single review, I already knew this was going to be a “big room, lights off, volume up” record. It did not disappoint.


Track by track

Side A

1. Beautiful Lie — Opens the record like a statement of intent. Big, forceful, guitars right up front. Amy’s voice has that same power it always had, but there’s a rawness to the mix here that feels earned rather than polished away. A strong, confident way to kick off four sides of vinyl.

2. Tell Me When You’ve Had Enough — This one leans into the heavier, more modern production Cervini and Fish bring to the table. It’s got teeth. On vinyl the low-end distortion has real weight to it — this is a track that wants to be played loud, not through earbuds.

3. Who Will You Follow — The lead single, and it’s obvious why. It’s the most “classic Evanescence” moment on side A — soaring chorus, that unmistakable voice cutting through a wall of guitar. Hearing it on wax rather than the radio edit gives it a bit more grit round the edges, which I much prefer.

4. Rapture — Closes out side A on a slightly more melodic, less aggressive note. A good palate cleanser before flipping the record — it breathes a little more than the two tracks before it.

Side B

5. Afterlife — This is the one that’s been everywhere, and on vinyl you understand why it connected the way it did. It’s anthemic without tipping into cheese, and there’s a real lift in the chorus that just lands differently through a proper set of speakers than it does compressed on a playlist.

6. Sanctuary — The title track, and it feels like the emotional centre of the record. Slower build, more space in the mix, Amy’s vocal takes centre stage rather than fighting the guitars for it. This is the track I’ve gone back to drop the needle on more than any other so far.

7. How Do I Heal — A quieter, more reflective moment. There’s real vulnerability here, and it’s a nice contrast tucked into the middle of the record rather than saved purely for a ballad-shaped closer.

8. Wide Open Heart (pressed here to close side B on this edition) — A big, cathartic swell of a track. Feels like a mini-finale within the record’s own arc, which makes turning the disc over feel like a genuine pause rather than just a mechanical need to flip vinyl.

Side C

9. About Us — Side C opens with something a bit more direct and confrontational. It’s got a sharper, almost personal edge to the lyrics, and the production here feels the most “2026” of anything on the record — you can hear Fish’s fingerprints on this one clearly.

10. Calm Down — A slight tonal shift, moodier and more restrained. Good sequencing decision — after the density of the first two sides, this gives the record room to exhale again.

11. Forever Without You — Piano-led, restrained, devastating in the way only Amy Lee at a piano can be. This is the sort of track that vinyl was made for — no rush, no skip button, just letting it sit in the room with you.

12. Self Destruct — Closes the whole record out on a heavier, more unresolved note rather than a tidy bow. It’s a bold choice for a closer, but it left me wanting to flip straight back to side A rather than feeling like the story had neatly wrapped up — which, on reflection, might be exactly the point.

Side D

Blank (etched pattern)


Final thoughts

I’ve bought a lot of records this year, mostly cheap finds cleaned up at the kitchen table, but Sanctuary is one of the few new releases I’ve actually sought out and paid full price for — and on the strength of these four sides, I don’t regret it. It’s a record that rewards being played properly: loud, uninterrupted, on a system that can handle the low end Cervini and Fish have built into it.

Is it as immediate as Fallen? No — nothing probably ever will be, that album is lightning in a bottle and everyone knows it. But Sanctuary isn’t trying to be that record again. It’s a band in their forties making a heavier, more deliberate, more emotionally raw album than anyone had any right to expect from a “comeback.” The sequencing across the four sides is genuinely thoughtful — there’s a real arc from the aggression of side A through to the quiet devastation of side D — and that’s the sort of structure you only really appreciate on vinyl, where the format forces you to sit with each side as its own little chapter.

If you grew up with this band the way I did, it’s worth the money for the title track and “Forever Without You” alone. Put it on, don’t touch your phone, let all four sides play through. It’s the kind of record that still has something to say.

Verdict: a genuinely great return — heavier, moodier, and more considered than a “comeback” record has any right to be.

Buy this record at Boiler Room Records (opens in a new tab)

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.