Vinyl Review

Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge — My Chemical Romance (2004)

By ·

Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge — My Chemical Romance (2004)

This one wasn’t planned. I was in Boiler Room Records in Poole doing my usual crate-digging, not really looking for anything in particular, when I flicked past this and just… grabbed it. I’ll be honest, My Chemical Romance have never really been on my radar — I know “Helena” exists, I know the eyeliner-and-black-hair aesthetic, I know they’re the band everyone who was a teenager in the mid-2000s has strong feelings about, but I never actually sat down and listened to one of their records properly. This felt like the right way to fix that — an impulse buy, no expectations, no nostalgia to live up to, just a record pulled off the shelf and taken home.

So this review comes from a genuinely fresh set of ears. No emotional attachment, no “this soundtracked my teenage years” baggage that so much of MCR’s fanbase carries around with this album. Just me, a turntable, and twenty years’ worth of other people’s hype to either live up to or not.

First impression pulling it out of the sleeve: that album art is properly striking, all blood-red and gothic, and it sets the tone before the needle’s even hit the groove.


Track by track

Side A

1. Helena — Straight in with the big one, and I understand the fuss now. That opening drum roll into the chorus is enormous, theatrical in a way that catches you off guard if, like me, you only knew it as “that song.” Genuinely a great opener.

2. Give ‘Em Hell, Kid — Faster, scrappier, more obviously punk than I expected going in. Good energy, keeps the momentum from the opener going without repeating it.

3. To The End — A bit more melodic, almost glam in places. This is where I started to hear the theatricality that apparently defines this whole record — it’s not just angry, it’s staged, almost.

4. You Know What They Do To Guys Like Us In Prison — Odd title, and a genuinely odd, off-kilter track to match. This is the one that made me sit up a bit — there’s something quite unhinged and gleeful about it that I wasn’t expecting from a “sad emo band.”

5. I’m Not Okay (I Promise) — The other song I already half-knew, and again, hearing it in full context rather than as a stray radio memory changes it completely. It’s a proper hook-laden pop-punk single dressed up in eyeliner, and it works.

6. The Ghost Of You — This might be my favourite discovery on side A. Genuinely emotional without tipping into melodrama, and there’s a real sense of dynamics here — quiet verses building into something much bigger.

7. The Jetset Life Is Gonna Kill You — A strong way to close out side A, a bit more swaggering and glam-rock than anything before it on the record.

Side B

8. Interlude — Short, moody, does its job as a palate cleanser between the two halves of the album. Not something I’d seek out on its own, but it earns its place as a breather.

9. Thank You For The Venom — Straight back into it with real bite. This is a heavier, more aggressive moment than most of side A, and it works as a jolt after the interlude.

10. Hang ‘Em High — Fast, direct, and pretty relentless. Coming to this cold, it’s the track that made me understand why this band got lumped in with the punkier end of the emo scene rather than just the sad-ballad end.

11. It’s Not A Fashion Statement, It’s A Deathwish — Genuinely one of the best titles I’ve come across on a record in a while, and the song lives up to it — sharp, sneering, self-aware.

12. Cemetery Drive — A moodier, more atmospheric turn, and probably the track that best shows off what the band can do when they slow things down without losing intensity.

13. I Never Told You What I Do For A Living — Closes the record out with real weight. It doesn’t feel like a tacked-on final track, it feels like the whole album has been building toward something, and this is it.


Final thoughts

Coming into this completely cold, as a genuine impulse buy off a shelf in Boiler Room Records rather than something I sought out, I wasn’t expecting to enjoy it as much as I did. I went in assuming I’d get a couple of singles I already half-recognised surrounded by filler, and instead got a record that’s far more theatrical, varied, and genuinely well-sequenced than its reputation as “that emo album” suggested to me.

It’s not a genre I’d have picked up on my own, and I still don’t think I’ll be diving headfirst into the rest of the MCR back catalogue tomorrow — but I’m glad this one ended up in my hands. That’s honestly the best kind of record shop find: not the one you went in looking for, but the one that makes you rethink a band, or a genre, you’d written off without really listening.

Verdict: a genuinely rewarding blind buy — more theatrical and varied than its reputation suggests, and proof that the best finds are the ones you weren’t looking for.

Buy this record at Boiler Room Records (opens in a new tab)

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.