Vinyl Review

Madonna – Finally Enough Love

By ·

Madonna – Finally Enough Love

2 x LP, Clear Vinyl | Rhino / Warner Records | 2022


Opening

There’s something fitting about finding a dance record in a shop called Boiler Room Records, and this one was waiting for me in the racks in Poole. Finally Enough Love is the 16-track, double-vinyl cut-down of Madonna’s 50 Number Onesproject, put together to mark her becoming the first artist to score fifty chart-toppers on a single Billboard chart (the Dance Club Songs chart). Rather than a greatest hits of radio edits, Madonna curated this herself as a set of her favourite club remixes, and it plays like a four-decade DJ set.

The packaging is smart: a gatefold sleeve with identical inner sleeves, and two crystal-clear discs that look terrific spinning under a light. The concept is neat too. Each side is dedicated to a decade: Side A is the ’80s, Side B the ’90s, Side C the ’00s and Side D the ’10s. Mine is the clear variant, pressed in France, and it arrived flat and quiet with no noticeable surface noise on first play.


Track Listing

Side A – The ’80s

A1. Everybody (You Can Dance Remix Edit) – 4:34
Her first ever single opens proceedings, in the Bruce Forest and Frank Heller mix from 1987’s You Can Dance. The original single dates from 1982. It’s raw, early-Manhattan club pop with a dubby, spacious feel, and it’s a lovely nod to where it all began.

A2. Into The Groove (You Can Dance Remix Edit) – 4:47
Shep Pettibone’s remix, with Andy Wallace engineering, of the 1985 classic. It’s punchy and bright, with the bassline carrying real weight on vinyl. It’s arguably the highlight of Side A.

A3. Like A Prayer (Remix/Edit) – 5:43
Bill Bottrell’s remix of the 1989 masterpiece. The gospel choir still gives you goosebumps, although the club treatment tones down some of the drama of the album version. It’s still a thrilling listen at volume.

A4. Express Yourself (Remix/Edit) – 5:02
Another Pettibone job, with Bob Rosa engineering. The 1989 original’s brassy funk translates brilliantly to a dancefloor pulse. It’s confident, swaggering, and it closes the side in style.

Side B – The ’90s

B1. Vogue (Single Version) – 4:21
Interestingly, this is the straight 1990 single rather than a remix, and there’s no complaint here. Pettibone’s production still sounds immaculate, and the deep house groove sits beautifully on the clear wax.

B2. Deeper And Deeper (David’s Radio Edit) – 4:04
David Morales takes on the 1992 Erotica-era single. It’s joyous, disco-tinged and bursting with energy. This is an underrated gem that deserves more airtime.

B3. Secret (Junior’s Luscious Single Mix) – 4:15
Junior Vasquez reworks the 1994 Bedtime Stories single into something silky and late-night. It’s a nice change of pace, and one of the more sophisticated mixes in the set.

B4. Frozen (Extended Club Mix Edit) – 4:38
Victor Calderone’s take on the 1998 Ray of Light single turns William Orbit’s brooding original into a driving club track, while keeping the chilly string drama intact. It’s a superb side-closer.

Side C – The ’00s

C1. Music (Deep Dish Dot Com Radio Edit) – 4:14
Deep Dish (Dubfire & Sharam) remix the 2000 hit. It’s more progressive and hypnotic than Mirwais’s quirky original, so it may split opinion, but it works well in this sequence.

C2. Hollywood (Calderone & Quayle Edit) – 4:02
The 2003 American Life single, reworked by Victor Calderone and Mac Quayle. It’s tougher and more polished than the original. This is a fine inclusion from an often-overlooked era.

C3. Hung Up (SDP Extended Vocal Edit) – 4:59
Stuart Price’s own extended mix of the 2005 smash. The ABBA sample kicks in and the room lights up. It’s pure euphoria, and possibly the best track on the whole record.

C4. Give It 2 Me (Eddie Amador Club 5 Edit) – 4:56
Eddie Amador’s remix of the 2008 Neptunes-produced single. It’s pounding, repetitive in the best sense and built for peak time.

Side D – The ’10s

D1. Girl Gone Wild (Avicii’s UMF Mix) – 5:15
The late Tim Bergling’s festival-sized remix of the 2012 MDNA single. It’s big-room and bright, and it carries a touch of poignancy now.

D2. Living For Love (Offer Nissim Promo Mix) – 5:52
This is the collection’s genuine rarity: the Offer Nissim promo mix of the 2014 Rebel Heart lead single, making its first official appearance here. It’s warm, gospel-lifted house, and collectors will want it for this track alone.

D3. Medellín (Offer Nissim Madame X In The Sphinx Mix) – with Maluma – 5:29
Nissim again, this time on the 2019 Madame X single. It stretches the reggaeton lilt of the original into an elegant, rolling house groove.

D4. I Don’t Search I Find (Honey Dijon Radio Mix) – 5:22
Honey Dijon’s mix of the Madame X track (2019) closes the set. It’s sleek, jacking and classy. As the last track on the record, it sends you out on a cool, understated note rather than a big bang.


Production Notes

Mastering

The whole collection was newly remastered by Mike Dean, the producer who worked on Rebel Heart (2015) and Madame X (2019), assisted by Sean Solymar. The vinyl lacquers were cut by Joe Nino-Hernes. Dean’s approach favours punch and modern loudness. That suits the club material, but the ’80s tracks sometimes lose a little of their original air and dynamics. On a decent system, though, the low end is solid and the top end crisp without harshness.

Recording and Engineering

As a compilation spanning nearly forty years, there’s no single recording engineer. Instead, the credits read like a who’s who of dance engineering:

  • Andy Wallace on “Into The Groove”
  • Robert Salcedo on “Like A Prayer”
  • Bob Rosa on “Express Yourself”
  • John Poppo on “Deeper And Deeper”
  • P. Dennis Mitchell on “Secret”
  • Dave Saronson and Victor Calderone, with John Gallo assisting, on “Frozen”
  • Richard Morel alongside Deep Dish on “Music”

Considering how many studios, eras and engineers are involved, the sound across the four sides is impressively consistent, which is largely down to the remastering.

The Label

The record was released through Rhino Records in partnership with Warner Records (catalogue number R1 695110; the clear variant’s sticker carries R1 695182). It was manufactured and marketed by Rhino Entertainment, Warner Music Group’s catalogue arm, and pressed in France. The release marked the start of Madonna’s career-spanning catalogue partnership with Warner, and Rhino’s reputation for careful reissues shows in the presentation.

Release Dates

  • This edition: 19 August 2022
  • Original recordings: As a remastered compilation, the source material spans 1982 (“Everybody”) to 2019 (“Medellín” and “I Don’t Search I Find”), with several mixes originally appearing on the 1987 remix album You Can Dance. The Offer Nissim Promo Mix of “Living For Love” was previously unreleased.

Final Thoughts

Finally Enough Love isn’t a greatest hits in the traditional sense, and anyone expecting the familiar single versions may be caught off guard. Taken on its own terms, though, as a personally curated club journey through four decades, it’s a lot of fun. The decade-per-side structure makes it easy to dip in and out, the clear vinyl looks the part, and the pressing is quiet and well centred.

The ’90s side is the strongest run of tracks. “Hung Up” is the moment that’ll have you reaching for the volume. The rare “Living For Love” mix gives collectors a real reason to own it. The modern remastering won’t please every purist, particularly on the early material, but for a record designed to be played loud, it does the job.

It’s a worthy addition for any Madonna fan or dance music collector, and a great find from an independent shop.

Buy this record at Boiler Room Records (opens in a new tab)

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.