The Monkees – Pisces, Aquarius, Capricorn & Jones Ltd.(2025 Rhino High Fidelity Pressing)

I reviewed this album as a 1967 record, but this time it’s the 2025 pressing, and the pressing is the story. I’m an independent-shop crate-digger by habit, and a modern reissue isn’t normally where my head goes, but this one is different. It’s a collector’s piece: a limited, numbered, gatefold edition made with obvious care. If you’ve only ever heard the Monkees through a tinny old copy, this is a very different experience, and it’s worth hearing even if you’re sceptical about reissues.
Side One
- Salesman: A breezy, offbeat opener. The extra definition on this pressing shows up immediately, and the instruments feel properly separated.
- She Hangs Out: Punchy and cheeky, with plenty of energy. It’s good to hear it with some real weight behind it.
- The Door into Summer: Warm and melodic. The vocal harmonies sound richer here than I’d expect from the era.
- Love Is Only Sleeping: Moody and dreamy. The stereo placement suits this one, and it’s one of the album’s underrated highlights.
- Cuddly Toy: Light and playful, with a jaunty swing that’s easy to enjoy.
- Words: A Boyce & Hart song, and a strong close to side one. It peaked at No. 11 on the Billboard chart.
Side Two
- Hard to Believe: A gentle, romantic start to side two.
- What Am I Doing Hangin’ ‘Round?: Michael Nesmith takes the lead on this country-rocker. It has a curiously compelling song structure, and it’s a real standout.
- Peter Percival Patterson’s Pet Pig Porky: Deliberate silliness, and the Monkees’ sense of humour at its most playful.
- Pleasant Valley Sunday: The big hit, which reached No. 3 on the Billboard chart. The harmonies and the huge reverb crash at the end are the real treat on a pressing like this.
- Daily Nightly: Strange, atmospheric and psychedelic, and the most experimental thing here.
- Don’t Call On Me: A quieter, bluesy track with a reflective mood.
- Star Collector: A driving, sharp closer. It was such a hit in Japan that the album was resequenced there to open with it.
The original 1967 recordings were made at RCA studios in Hollywood, New York and Nashville. The album was produced by Chip Douglas, and the original recording engineers were Hank Cicalo and Pete Abbott. For this 2025 pressing, the vinyl was cut from the original analog master tapes, AAA, by Kevin Gray at Cohearent Audio, with Andrew Sandoval handling A&R supervision. It was pressed at Optimal in Germany.
- It’s described as the first vinyl pressing sourced directly from the unaltered 1967 stereo master, released on 3 October 2025. The original Colgems LPs had gone through extra generations of copying, with EQ, level and compression changes made for consistent cuts at RCA’s pressing plants.
- It was pressed on 180-gram black vinyl and limited to 5,000 individually numbered copies.
- It comes in a gatefold sleeve, which the original LP never had, with a glossy laminated cover and an obi-style information strip.
- It was sold exclusively through Rhino’s webstore. If you’d normally rather buy from an indie shop, that’s worth knowing.
- It doesn’t use the original Colgems labels, which is a small quibble for purists.
- The original album spent five weeks at No. 1 on the Billboard 200 and earned double platinum certification.
- It was one of the earliest uses of a Moog synthesizer on a rock album.
- Session players include Chip Douglas, Doug Dillard, Eddie Hoh and Moog pioneer Paul Beaver.
- The songwriters include Jeff Barry, Leiber & Stoller, Ellie Greenwich and Harry Nilsson, as well as Goffin-King and Boyce & Hart.
This is the version of the album I’d point people towards. The music is the same, but the sound is richer, fuller and punchier than the older pressings, and the extra care in the packaging adds to the experience. It’s still a mid-’60s pop record at heart, so don’t expect modern hi-fi sheen, but you can hear the instruments properly now. For a record that’s often dismissed, it deserves this treatment. If you’ve ever wondered whether a reissue can justify the price, this one makes a good case.