Vinyl Review

Records to Give This Christmas (2026)

By ·

The 2026 gift guides aren’t out yet, so this is my own selection. I’ve written full reviews of five classic albums that make reliable presents, each available in good current pressings, with one deliberately seasonal pick. A shorter list of 2026 releases follows, for anyone who’d rather give something new.


1. Marvin Gaye — What’s Going On (1971)

Label: Tamla / Motown · Producer: Marvin Gaye · For: soul fans, anyone who loved the Isaac Hayes and Donna Summer records

Introduction

In 1970, Marvin Gaye was Motown’s most reliable hitmaker, and he was miserable. His duet partner Tammi Terrell had died of a brain tumor, his brother Frankie had returned from Vietnam with stories of horror, and America was tearing itself apart. Gaye’s response was a song cycle about war, poverty, the environment and faith.

Berry Gordy reportedly called the title track “the worst thing I ever heard” and refused to release it. Gaye went on strike until Motown relented. The single was a huge hit, and the album became one of the most acclaimed records ever made. In 2020 it topped Rolling Stone‘s list of the 500 greatest albums.

Track Listing

Side One

  1. What’s Going On. Renaldo “Obie” Benson of the Four Tops co-wrote it with Al Cleveland. Eli Fontaine’s sax opening was reportedly him warming up, and Gaye kept it. The party chatter features Detroit Lions players Mel Farr and Lem Barney. It reached US No. 2.
  2. What’s Happening Brother. The returning Vietnam veteran’s view, inspired by Frankie Gaye. It flows straight out of the title track. The album plays as a continuous suite.
  3. Flyin’ High (In the Friendly Sky). A haunting song about heroin addiction, with Gaye’s falsetto at its most fragile.
  4. Save the Children. Gaye half-speaks and half-sings in a dialogue with his own overdubbed voice. It’s one of the album’s most spiritual moments.
  5. God Is Love. A short, joyful hymn that leads into the next track.
  6. Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology). One of the first mainstream pop songs about environmental damage. It’s gorgeous, mournful and still relevant, and it reached US No. 4.

Side Two
7. Right On. A seven-minute Latin-jazz-soul groove with flute and congas, and the album’s loosest, most improvised piece.
8. Wholy Holy. A gospel-soul prayer, later famously covered by Aretha Franklin.
9. Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler). A dark, simmering portrait of urban poverty and police brutality. It reached US No. 9, and its loping groove has been sampled endlessly.

Details for enthusiasts

  • Studios: recorded at Hitsville U.S.A. (Motown’s famous “Snakepit” Studio A) and Motown’s Golden World studio (Studio B) in Detroit in 1970–71. Gaye rejected an early mix made in Los Angeles and remixed the album in Detroit.
  • The band: the Funk Brothers, Motown’s legendary house musicians, including James Jamerson on bass. A famous story says he recorded his part lying on the floor because he was too drunk to sit up. Also playing are Eddie “Bongo” Brown and Jack Ashford on percussion, and members of the Detroit Symphony Orchestra.
  • Arrangements: David Van DePitte wrote the lush strings and horns.
  • Multitrack vocals: Gaye layered his own voice into a choir with himself. It was a new approach for soul, and it influenced everyone from Stevie Wonder to D’Angelo.

Gift verdict

This is one of the safest gifts in music: profound but completely accessible. Expect the recipient to keep it on repeat. Rating: 5 / 5.


2. Fleetwood Mac — Rumours (1977)

Label: Warner Bros. · Producers: Fleetwood Mac, Ken Caillat, Richard Dashut · For: almost anyone

Introduction

It’s the most famous soap opera in rock. During the making of Rumours, John and Christine McVie were divorcing, Lindsey Buckingham and Stevie Nicks were breaking up, and Mick Fleetwood’s marriage was collapsing. They wrote songs about one another, then sang the harmonies together. The result is one of the best-selling albums ever, at over 40 million copies. It won the 1978 Grammy for Album of the Year.

Track Listing

Side One

  1. Second Hand News. Buckingham’s bouncy breakup song. The percussion was reportedly partly played on a chair seat.
  2. Dreams. Nicks’s gentle, floating reply to Buckingham. It’s the band’s only US No. 1 single, and it had a second viral life on TikTok in 2020.
  3. Never Going Back Again. Buckingham’s intricate fingerpicked acoustic showpiece.
  4. Don’t Stop. Christine McVie’s upbeat anthem of optimism, later Bill Clinton’s 1992 campaign theme.
  5. Go Your Own Way. Buckingham’s bitter, driving rocker aimed at Nicks, who then had to sing backing vocals on it. Mick Fleetwood’s awkward, distinctive drum pattern was his attempt to play a groove Buckingham had in mind.
  6. Songbird. Christine alone at the piano. It was recorded at night in the empty Zellerbach Auditorium in Berkeley, with a bouquet of roses reportedly placed on the piano.

Side Two
7. The Chain. The only song credited to all five members, assembled from fragments of other songs. John McVie’s bass riff in the outro has been the theme for Formula 1 coverage on UK television since the 1970s.
8. You Make Loving Fun. Christine’s joyful song, about her affair with the band’s lighting director.
9. I Don’t Want to Know. A breezy country-rock duet, originally a Nicks song from her days with Buckingham.
10. Oh Daddy. Christine’s moody, slow tribute to Mick Fleetwood, the band’s “daddy.”
11. Gold Dust Woman. Nicks’s dark, mesmerising closer, widely read as being about cocaine.

Details for enthusiasts

  • Studios: mostly recorded at the Record Plant in Sausalito, California, with further work at Criteria Studios in Miami, Wally Heider and Sound City in Los Angeles, and other locations.
  • Tape wear: engineers Ken Caillat and Richard Dashut overdubbed so many times that the oxide began wearing off the master tape. They had to rush it onto safety copies.
  • “Silver Springs”: Nicks’s beautiful song was dropped from the album to save space and appeared only as a B-side. It’s now included on modern deluxe editions. Nicks reportedly never forgave the decision.
  • Pressings: standard Rhino/Warner reissues are widely available and reliable. The 2LP deluxe and box-set editions add demos and outtakes.

Gift verdict

It’s the definitive crowd-pleaser, and arguably the safest gift on this list. Rating: 5 / 5.


3. Kate Bush — Hounds of Love (1985)

Label: EMI (current reissues on Fish People) · Producer: Kate Bush · For: prog and art-pop fans, and anyone who loved Tubular Bells

Introduction

After the difficult, expensive The Dreaming (1982), Kate Bush built her own studio and took complete control of her next album. Hounds of Love was the result. Side one is a perfect run of art-pop singles. Side two, The Ninth Wave, is a conceptual suite about a woman adrift in freezing water at night.

It knocked Madonna’s Like a Virgin off UK No. 1. In 2022 it found a new generation when “Running Up That Hill” appeared in Stranger Things and became a global hit 37 years after its release.

Track Listing

Side One — Hounds of Love

  1. Running Up That Hill (A Deal with God). A pounding Fairlight rhythm, a yearning vocal, and the wish to swap places with your lover so you can understand each other. It’s one of the greatest singles of the decade. EMI reportedly made her soften the title, worried that radio would reject “God.”
  2. Hounds of Love. It opens with a sample from the 1957 horror film Night of the Demon (“It’s in the trees! It’s coming!”). It’s a thunderous, cello-driven song about the fear of being loved.
  3. The Big Sky. An exuberant, chant-driven celebration of cloud-watching.
  4. Mother Stands for Comfort. A dark, minimalist song, sung from the point of view of a killer protected by his mother. Eberhard Weber’s fretless bass gives it a ghostly feel.
  5. Cloudbusting. It’s inspired by Peter Reich’s memoir about his father, the psychoanalyst Wilhelm Reich, and his rain-making “cloudbuster” machine. Its relentless string pattern is irresistible. In the video, Donald Sutherland plays Reich.

Side Two — The Ninth Wave
6. And Dream of Sheep. A piano lullaby as the woman struggles to stay awake in the water.
7. Under Ice. A chilling, minimal piece about being trapped beneath frozen water.
8. Waking the Witch. A disorienting collage of voices, sampled speech and an accusatory witch trial.
9. Watching You Without Me. The woman as a ghost, watching her home and partner.
10. Jig of Life. An exhilarating Irish folk-influenced section, with traditional musicians recorded in Dublin.
11. Hello Earth. It’s built around a Georgian folk melody, “Tsintskaro,” sung by a choir. It’s an otherworldly view of the Earth from space and the album’s emotional high point.
12. The Morning Fog. Rescue and gratitude, a gentle, joyful ending.

Details for enthusiasts

  • Studio: recorded mainly at Bush’s newly built home studio at Wickham Farm in Kent, with sessions at Abbey Road and at Windmill Lane in Dublin for the Irish musicians.
  • Engineering: her long-time partner Del Palmer was central to the recording, along with engineers including Haydn Bendall. Brian Tench mixed it.
  • Technology: the Fairlight CMI sampler is everywhere. Bush was one of its most creative early users.
  • Remasters: in 2018, Bush supervised remasters of her whole catalog, released on her own Fish People label. Those vinyl editions are the ones to buy.

Gift verdict

It’s a perfect gift for an adventurous listener, and the side-two suite makes it a real album experience. Rating: 5 / 5.


4. Miles Davis — Kind of Blue (1959)

Label: Columbia · Producers: Teo Macero and Irving Townsend · For: anyone curious about jazz, and as a gift for someone who “doesn’t like jazz”

Introduction

Kind of Blue is the best-selling jazz album of all time, and probably the most loved. Miles Davis brought an extraordinary sextet into Columbia’s studio with only sketches of scales and modes, rather than conventional chord changes. Most of the album was recorded in first complete takes. The result is cool, spacious and lyrical, and it changed jazz.

Track Listing

Side One

  1. So What. Paul Chambers’s bass and Bill Evans’s piano play the famous call-and-response “so what” figure. It’s built on just two modes, and it’s the definitive statement of modal jazz.
  2. Freddie Freeloader. A relaxed blues with Wynton Kelly on piano instead of Evans. Kelly was the band’s regular pianist, and Davis felt his bluesier touch suited the piece.
  3. Blue in Green. A short, delicate ballad, and one of the most beautiful recordings in jazz. It’s credited to Davis, but Evans always maintained he wrote much of it.

Side Two
4. All Blues. A lilting 6/8 blues with a hypnotic, rocking groove.
5. Flamenco Sketches. A slow, meditative piece built on five modes, with the soloists taking turns. It’s a perfect closer.

Details for enthusiasts

  • Studio: Columbia’s 30th Street Studio in New York, a converted church famous for its natural reverb. It was recorded on 2 March and 22 April 1959.
  • Engineer: Fred Plaut, Columbia’s great staff engineer.
  • The band: Miles Davis (trumpet), John Coltrane (tenor sax), Cannonball Adderley (alto sax), Bill Evans and Wynton Kelly (piano), Paul Chambers (bass), Jimmy Cobb (drums). Each became a legend.
  • The speed error: one of the tape machines at the first session ran slightly slow. As a result, side one was released about a quarter-tone sharp and slightly fast. It went unnoticed for decades and was finally corrected on 1990s remasters. If the recipient owns an old copy, a new pressing will sound noticeably different.
  • Liner notes: written by Bill Evans, who compares the music to Japanese brush painting, an art where you can’t go back and correct mistakes.
  • Pressings: many editions are available, in mono and stereo. The standard Columbia/Legacy reissues are fine. For audiophiles, the premium audiophile editions in both mono and stereo are a treat.

Gift verdict

It’s the easiest way to introduce someone to jazz. Rating: 5 / 5.


5. Vince Guaraldi Trio — A Charlie Brown Christmas (1965)

Label: Fantasy (current reissues via Craft Recordings) · For: everyone, every year

Introduction

In 1965, CBS commissioned an animated special from the creators of Peanuts. Producer Lee Mendelson hired Vince Guaraldi, a San Francisco jazz pianist, to write the score. CBS executives were reportedly unhappy about using jazz and a real children’s choir, and expected the special to flop. Instead it became a TV institution, and its soundtrack became one of the best-selling Christmas albums ever. It’s warm, wistful and swinging, and gentle enough to play at a family dinner and good enough for a jazz fan.

Track Listing

Side One

  1. O Tannenbaum. A gently swinging version of the traditional carol.
  2. What Child Is This. A soft, reflective take on “Greensleeves.”
  3. My Little Drum. Based on “The Little Drummer Boy,” with a quiet wordless choir.
  4. Linus and Lucy. The famous Peanuts theme, with its bouncing left-hand piano figure. It’s instantly recognizable and pure joy.
  5. Christmas Time Is Here (Instrumental). A melancholy jazz waltz.

Side Two
6. Christmas Time Is Here (Vocal). Lee Mendelson wrote the lyrics, and children from St. Paul’s Episcopal Church in San Rafael sing it. Their slightly imperfect singing is part of its charm.
7. Skating. A sparkling, flowing waltz evoking children on ice.
8. Hark, the Herald Angels Sing. A short, sung finale, as in the TV special.
9. Christmas Is Coming. An upbeat, Latin-flavored original.
10. Für Elise. A brief, playful nod to Beethoven, as played by Schroeder.
11. The Christmas Song. A gentle, beautiful version of Mel Tormé’s classic.

Details for enthusiasts

  • The trio: Vince Guaraldi (piano), with Fred Marshall (bass) and Jerry Granelli (drums) on most tracks. Monty Budwig and Colin Bailey played on some sessions.
  • Recording: much of the album was recorded in San Francisco in late 1965. The choir was recorded separately.
  • Reissues: Craft Recordings releases new coloured-vinyl editions almost every year, and there are deluxe editions with alternate takes.
  • Legacy: “Linus and Lucy” and “Christmas Time Is Here” are now standard holiday tunes, covered by countless jazz and pop artists.

Gift verdict

It’s the ideal stocking filler. It’s inexpensive, works for all ages, and gets played every December for years. Rating: 5 / 5.


New for 2026: Something Recent to Give

I haven’t heard most of these, and some aren’t out yet, so these are suggestions based on what’s been announced, not reviews.

Out now (limited, so buy quickly)

  • Pink Floyd — Meddle, San Tropez orange vinyl: the National Album Day 2026 edition. Covered in an earlier review.
  • Mike Oldfield — Tubular Bells, Blue Seashore vinyl: the National Album Day edition with Miles Showell’s half-speed master. Also covered earlier.
  • Isaac Hayes — The Best of Isaac Hayes: the 2025 Craft compilation, available on red and “electric smoke” coloured vinyl. A good introduction for someone new to Hayes.

Due in November

  • Bob Dylan — The Rolling Thunder Revue: The 1976 Live Recordings (6 November): a natural choice for a Dylan fan.
  • Spice Girls — The Singles Collection (6 November): a fun, nostalgic gift for millennial pop fans.
  • Sufjan Stevens — Worst Christmas Ever! (6 November): his Christmas albums have a cult following, which makes this one a natural seasonal pick.
  • Dropkick Murphys — 20th Century Paddy: The Songs of Shane MacGowan (13 November): a tribute to the Pogues singer, whose “Fairytale of New York” is a Christmas standard. Pair it with If I Should Fall from Grace with God by the Pogues.
  • Take That — Dreamers (20 November): the obvious mainstream pop gift this year.
  • U2 — Carnaval de Luz (13 November) and Kings of Leon — ‘O My Beloved (6 November): see my previews in the previous message.

Gift Tips

  • Check the edition: for older albums, look for remasters supervised by the artist (like the Kate Bush 2018 editions) or reputable labels such as Craft, Rhino and Legacy.
  • Coloured vinyl: it looks great as a gift, but black vinyl is often slightly quieter. For an audiophile, black is the safer choice.
  • Keep the receipt: pressing faults happen, so a gift receipt is useful.
  • Pair the record with something: inner sleeves, a record brush or a book about the artist make a simple record into a thoughtful gift.

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.