The Sisters of Mercy — First and Last and Always (1985)

40th Anniversary Box Set · Released: 4 July 2025 · Label: Merciful Release / Warner (listed by some retailers as Elektra)
Format: the album on LP plus three 12″ EPs on 45 RPM, on black and red marble vinyl
Introduction
First and Last and Always is the debut album by the Sisters of Mercy and one of the defining records of British goth rock. Andrew Eldritch would hate that description: he has spent forty years insisting the band were never goth.
The Sisters began in Leeds in 1980 as a project between Andrew Eldritch and guitarist Gary Marx. Their drummer was a machine they called Doktor Avalanche. By 1984 they had built a cult following on independent singles and EPs. With Wayne Hussey (guitar) and Craig Adams (bass) on board, they signed to WEA and made this album.
It was released in March 1985 and reached UK No. 14. It’s a record of huge, chiming guitars, relentless machine beats and Eldritch’s sepulchral baritone, which sounds as if it’s coming from the bottom of a well.
The band was already falling apart. Gary Marx left during the album’s making, and by the end of 1985 Hussey and Adams had gone too, to form The Mission. Eldritch kept the name, and the Sisters’ story continued with Floodland(1987) and Vision Thing (1990), the band’s last studio album to date. So this box is a document of a lineup that made just one album together.
This 40th anniversary set combines the album with the three EPs that came out around it, each with their original non-album tracks.
The Album: First and Last and Always
Side A
1. Black Planet
A powerful opener with driving drum machine, swirling guitars and Eldritch’s doom-laden picture of an ecologically ruined world. It sets the album’s tone straight away.
2. Walk Away
The lead single. It’s jangling, urgent and catchy, with Hussey’s twelve-string-style guitar and a strong melody. It’s one of the band’s most immediate songs.
3. No Time to Cry
The second single. A dark, propulsive track with a pounding beat, a menacing riff and one of Eldritch’s best vocals.
4. A Rock and a Hard Place
A tense, stormy song with a huge guitar sound. It’s a fan favourite.
5. Marian (Version)
The album’s epic centrepiece. It’s slow, hypnotic and dramatic, and Eldritch sings part of it in German, which adds to its strange, gothic atmosphere. Many fans consider it the band’s masterpiece.
Side B
6. First and Last and Always
The title track is one of the band’s most melodic songs. It has a chiming, romantic guitar line and a strong, almost anthemic chorus. Hussey co-wrote it, and you can hear the melodic instinct he later took to The Mission.
7. Possession
A heavy, driving song with an ominous riff and a relentless beat.
8. Nine While Nine
A slower, brooding song with an eerie atmosphere and a superb vocal from Eldritch.
9. Logic
A fast, aggressive track with harsh, metallic guitars. It’s one of the album’s most energetic songs.
10. Some Kind of Stranger
A seven-minute closer that builds slowly into an enormous, emotional climax, with backing vocals and layers of guitar. It’s one of the most powerful endings to any album of the 1980s.
The EPs
Body and Soul (1984)
- A: Body and Soul · Body Electric
- B: Train · Afterhours
This was the band’s first release on WEA, from 1984, before the album. “Body and Soul” is dark, propulsive and tense. “Body Electric” is an earlier Sisters song included here as an extra. “Train” has become a live favourite, with a pounding, mechanical rhythm. “Afterhours” is a moody, atmospheric deep cut.
Walk Away (1984)
- A: Walk Away
- B: Poison Door · On the Wire
The single version of the album’s second track. The B-sides are excellent. “Poison Door” is one of the band’s best songs and fully the equal of the album tracks. “On the Wire” is dark and atmospheric.
No Time to Cry (1985)
- A: No Time to Cry
- B: Blood Money · Bury Me Deep
The final single from the album, with two strong B-sides. “Blood Money” is fast and aggressive. “Bury Me Deep” is slow, brooding and doomy.
Recording and Enthusiast Details
The lineup
- Andrew Eldritch: vocals and songwriting. He also programmed Doktor Avalanche.
- Wayne Hussey: guitars. He joined from Dead or Alive and wrote or co-wrote much of the album’s music.
- Gary Marx: guitars and co-founder. He left during the making of the album and later formed Ghost Dance.
- Craig Adams: bass. He later co-founded The Mission and played in The Cult.
- Doktor Avalanche: the band’s drum machine, which they always credited as a band member. The machine itself was upgraded over the years, but the “Doktor” was always listed.
Production
- Producer: David M. Allen, who also produced The Cure and The Associates. His spacious, reverb-heavy production defined the album’s sound.
- Sessions: the album was recorded in 1984 at several studios, including Strawberry Studios in Stockport. The sessions were reportedly long, difficult and tense, with arguments, exhaustion and Eldritch’s perfectionism all contributing to the lineup’s collapse.
- Eldritch’s role: he was notorious for long, sleepless sessions. He reportedly did vocals at night and lived on stimulants. He collapsed from exhaustion at one point during the making of the album.
What happened next
- The Mission: Hussey and Adams left in late 1985 and formed The Mission, briefly called The Sisterhood. Eldritch released an album under that name first, partly to stop them using it. The two camps remained bitter rivals for years.
- Floodland (1987): Eldritch made it with Patricia Morrison, with Jim Steinman co-producing some tracks. It brought the band’s biggest hits, “This Corrosion” and “Dominion/Mother Russia.”
- No new album since 1990: following a dispute with their record company, the Sisters haven’t released a studio album since Vision Thing in 1990. They still tour and play new songs live, and that makes their old catalog all the more precious to fans.
About the 40th Anniversary Box Set
- Released: 4 July 2025.
- Contents: the original album on LP, plus the Body and Soul, Walk Away and No Time to Cry EPs on 12″ vinyl at 45 RPM. Playing at 45 gives the EPs extra dynamic range and bass, which suits their huge sound.
- Vinyl: black and red marble. Some retailers note that colours may vary.
- Why it matters: the EPs gather songs that never appeared on the album, including “Poison Door,” “Train” and “Body and Soul.” This gives you the whole of this lineup’s recorded work from the period in one place, as it was originally released.
- What isn’t included: the sources I found don’t give mastering credits or say whether the set includes a booklet, poster or other extras. Check what came in your box.
- Price: retailers list it at roughly £97–£108.
Final Thoughts
First and Last and Always is one of the essential albums of the 1980s alternative scene. Its sound, with Eldritch’s voice, the machine beats and the huge, chiming guitars, has influenced everyone from Type O Negative to modern post-punk bands. It’s dramatic and gloomy but also melodic and surprisingly catchy. “Marian,” “Some Kind of Stranger,” “Walk Away” and the title track are among the band’s finest moments.
The box set makes it even better. The EPs are full of essential non-album tracks, especially “Poison Door,” “Body and Soul” and “Train,” and having everything from this short-lived lineup in one place makes this the definitive version.
Highlights: “Marian,” “Some Kind of Stranger,” “First and Last and Always,” “Walk Away,” and from the EPs, “Poison Door.”
Weakest moment: “Logic.” It’s energetic, but less memorable than the rest.