Vinyl Review

Foo Fighters — Your Favorite Toy (2026)

By ·

Foo Fighters — Your Favorite Toy (2026)

Labels: Roswell / RCA / Sony Music · Catalog: 19958-44213-1 / 19958-44216-1 · Format: LP on opaque white vinyl
Released: 24 April 2026 · Producers: Foo Fighters and Oliver Roman · Mixing: Mark “Spike” Stent · Mastering: Randy Merrill


Introduction

Few bands have been through as much in recent years as Foo Fighters. In March 2022 drummer Taylor Hawkins died suddenly on tour in Colombia. Later that year came two emotional tribute concerts. In 2023 the band released But Here We Are, a raw album of grief made partly in response to Hawkins’s death and the death of Dave Grohl’s mother, Virginia. Grohl played drums on it himself. Josh Freese then joined as touring drummer, but he left in 2025. Grohl also faced a very public personal crisis in 2024.

Your Favorite Toy, their 12th album, is a response to all of that, and a deliberate return to energy and volume. It’s the first album with new drummer Ilan Rubin, best known from Nine Inch Nails and Angels & Airwaves. At 36 minutes, it’s one of the band’s shortest albums. Critics welcomed it as their leanest, loudest record in decades.

It reached No. 2 in the UK and No. 1 on the UK Rock & Metal chart.


Track Listing

All songs are credited to Foo Fighters.

Side A

1. Caught in the Echo (4:02)
The opener and third single, released 20 March 2026.

2. Of All People (2:34)
The fourth single, released two weeks before the album. It’s one of the album’s shortest tracks.

3. Window (3:37)

4. Your Favorite Toy (2:56)
The title track and second single, released 19 February 2026 when the album was announced. Grohl has said this was the song that set the album’s direction after a long period of experimenting. Its original title was “For Good,” from a lyric in the chorus. Grohl changed it after Wicked: For Good was announced, to avoid any confusion. Harper Grohl, Dave’s daughter, sings backing vocals.

5. If You Only Knew (4:00)

Side B

6. Spit Shine (3:21)
Rami Jaffee plays a theremin on this track, an unusual sound for a Foo Fighters record.

7. Unconditional (4:16)

8. Child Actor (3:45)

9. Amen, Caveman (3:16)
The most criticised track. PopMatters singled out its lyrics as a weak point.

10. Asking for a Friend (4:29)
The album’s first single, released in October 2025, six months before the album.


Recording and Enthusiast Details

The lineup

  • Dave Grohl: vocals, guitar
  • Pat Smear: guitar. He was also in Nirvana’s final touring lineup and in the Germs.
  • Chris Shiflett: guitar
  • Nate Mendel: bass
  • Rami Jaffee: keyboards, piano, theremin
  • Ilan Rubin: drums. He’s a multi-instrumentalist and a former member of Nine Inch Nails, Angels & Airwaves, Paramore’s touring band and Lostprophets.

Recording

  • Studios: recorded during 2024–2025 at Grohl’s home studio and the band’s own Studio 606 in Los Angeles.
  • The demos: Grohl wrote and demoed more than 50 songs. Early influences included Massive Attack, Pink Floyd and Bad Brains, a wide range that suggests how much they tried before settling on a direction.
  • Recorded live: Grohl and Rubin recorded the rhythm tracks together, playing live without a click track. The other members then overdubbed their parts. This approach gives the drums and guitars a looser, more human push, similar to classic rock recordings.
  • No Greg Kurstin: it’s the band’s first album since Sonic Highways (2014) not produced by Greg Kurstin, who produced Concrete and Gold, Medicine at Midnight and But Here We Are. Instead the band produced it themselves with Oliver Roman, their in-house engineer.
  • Mixing: Mark “Spike” Stent mixed it. His credits include Massive Attack, U2, Muse, Oasis and Björk.
  • Mastering: Randy Merrill, with Bob Demaa assisting. Merrill is one of the most in-demand mastering engineers in pop and rock.
  • Artwork: design and art direction by Morning Breath Inc.

Promotion

  • The band announced two secret club shows during release week: Irving Plaza in New York (capacity 1,200) on 30 April and the Starland Ballroom in New Jersey (capacity 2,500) on 2 May. That’s a tiny audience for a band that plays stadiums.
  • A world tour followed from mid-2026.

Critical Reception

Reviews were generally favourable, with a Metacritic score of 74 from 21 reviews.

  • Pitchfork: “the leanest, meanest Foo Fighters album in 30 years.”
  • Rolling Stone: said it contains “some of the most powerful music” the band has made.
  • NME: compared it favourably with the band’s early albums.
  • Positive scores: AllMusic, Kerrang!, Mojo and The Independent each gave it 4/5, Clash gave 8/10 and Consequence gave a B.
  • More critical: The A.V. Club found it “far from convincingly inspired.” The Arts Desk gave it 3/5, and PopMatters criticised the lyrics.

Charts

  • UK: No. 2, and No. 1 on the Rock & Metal chart
  • Germany: No. 2
  • Australia: No. 3
  • New Zealand: No. 4
  • US Billboard 200: No. 23, and No. 3 on the Top Rock & Alternative Albums chart

The US position is low by the band’s standards. It suggests their audience is now stronger in Europe and Australasia than at home.


About This Pressing

  • Opaque white vinyl: this is one of several colours. A red edition was also sold through some retailers.
  • Short sides: the album runs about 36 minutes, so each side is only about 18 minutes long.
  • Coloured vinyl: as with the other coloured editions, white vinyl can be a little noisier than black.

Final Thoughts

By most accounts, Your Favorite Toy is a strong comeback. It’s short, loud and direct, and after years of grief and turmoil it found the band focusing on what they do best. The live rhythm tracks with Ilan Rubin, Spike Stent’s mix and Grohl’s decision to cut a pile of demos down to ten songs all seem to have helped. Critics called it the band’s leanest record in decades.

Not everyone was convinced. Some reviewers found it formulaic, and the lyrics, especially on “Amen, Caveman,” came in for criticism. But the overall response was the warmest the band has had in years.

Buy this record at Boiler Room Records (opens in a new tab)

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.