Vinyl Review

Fine Young Cannibals — The Raw & the Cooked (1989)

By ·

Fine Young Cannibals — The Raw & the Cooked (1989)

This copy: London Records 828 069.1 · LP · Stereo · UK · Released 6 February 1989


Introduction

Fine Young Cannibals formed in Birmingham in 1984. Guitarist Andy Cox and bassist/keyboardist David Steele came from The Beat, the two-tone band behind “Mirror in the Bathroom.” When The Beat split, they auditioned singers and found Roland Gift, a former punk and actor with a remarkable, high, cracked soul voice. The band name came from the 1960 film All the Fine Young Cannibals.

Their self-titled debut (1985) was a hit, with “Johnny Come Home” and a cover of Elvis’s “Suspicious Minds.” The follow-up took almost four years, as the band contributed songs and appearances to films and Gift pursued acting.

When The Raw & the Cooked finally arrived, it was a phenomenon. It reached No. 1 in both the UK and the US, and it produced two US No. 1 singles. It’s one of the best pop albums of the late 1980s, combining classic 1960s soul, Motown and Northern Soul with modern dance production, house beats and new wave.


Track Listing

Side One

1. She Drives Me Crazy
One of the defining singles of 1989. It’s built on a famous, distinctive snare drum sound, a huge, dry “crack,” and a jittery guitar riff. Gift’s falsetto over it is unforgettable. It was recorded with David Z, Prince’s long-time engineer and collaborator, at Prince’s Paisley Park studios in Minneapolis. It reached US No. 1 and UK No. 5.

2. Good Thing
A joyful, piano-driven 1960s-style rhythm and blues song in the style of Motown and Stax. It was first heard in Barry Levinson‘s 1987 film Tin Men, in which the band also appear performing. It became their second US No. 1 and reached UK No. 7.

3. I’m Not the Man I Used to Be
A darker, more modern track with a programmed hip-hop-influenced beat and a melancholy, regretful vocal. It shows the band’s more contemporary side and reached the UK Top 20.

4. I’m Not Satisfied
A punchy, energetic, dance-influenced song with a strong chorus, and another UK single.

5. Tell Me What
Another song from Tin Men. It’s a smooth, 1960s soul-style song that suits Gift’s voice perfectly.

Side Two

6. Don’t Look Back
A bright, jangling pop song with a strong melody. It was a hit in the US, reaching the Top 20, and in the UK.

7. It’s OK (It’s Alright)
A soulful, mid-tempo song with a classic feel.

8. Don’t Let It Get You Down
An upbeat, encouraging song with a danceable groove.

9. As Hard As It Is
A slow, moving ballad, and a showcase for Gift’s voice.

10. Ever Fallen in Love (With Someone You Shouldn’t’ve)
A cover of the Buzzcocks‘ 1978 punk classic, remade as a sleek, dance-pop soul track. It was first released in 1987 for Jonathan Demme’s film Something Wild, reaching UK No. 9. It’s a clever reworking, and the Buzzcocks’ Pete Shelley reportedly approved.


Enthusiast Details

The band

  • Roland Gift: vocals. As an actor he appeared in Sammy and Rosie Get Laid (1987) and Scandal (1989), in which he played Johnny Edgecombe.
  • Andy Cox: guitar, keyboards.
  • David Steele: bass, keyboards, programming.

Cox and Steele produced much of the album themselves, with outside producers on some tracks. The production combines live instruments, samples, drum machines and programming, which was cutting-edge for the time.

The title

The album takes its title from The Raw and the Cooked (1964), a book by the French anthropologist Claude Lévi-Strauss. In the band’s use, the title probably reflects the album’s mix of raw 1960s soul and polished modern production.

The long wait

The album took almost four years, partly because of Gift’s acting work and the band’s film soundtrack projects. That’s also why it includes three songs that had already been released: “Good Thing” and “Tell Me What” from Tin Men, and “Ever Fallen in Love” from Something Wild.

The Brit Awards controversy

At the 1990 Brit Awards, FYC won Best British Group and Best British Album. They then returned the awards. They said it was inappropriate to accept them while the event was associated with the Conservative government of Margaret Thatcher. Thatcher’s government was seen as close to the British music industry’s establishment, and the band objected to being part of that.

What came next

After The Raw & the Cooked, the band released a remix album, The Raw & the Remix (1990), and then went quiet. Apart from a new single in 1996, there was no third album. Roland Gift released a solo album in 2002, and Cox and Steele took on other projects. This was FYC’s last studio album, which makes it all the more treasured.


About My Pressing

  • What it is: the original UK London Records LP from February 1989, catalogue 828 069.1. London Records was FYC’s UK label, distributed by PolyGram.
  • Late vinyl era: 1989 was near the end of vinyl’s commercial life, as CD took over. Pressing quality varied, but UK PolyGram pressings of the period are generally good.
  • Common but desirable: the album sold in huge numbers, so original copies are plentiful and usually cheap. Look for a clean copy with the original inner sleeve, which carried lyrics and credits.
  • Sound: the album’s crisp production, especially that snare on “She Drives Me Crazy,” sounds very good on a clean original pressing.

Final Thoughts

The Raw & the Cooked is a near-perfect pop album. In just ten songs it moves from crisp, modern dance-pop (“She Drives Me Crazy,” “I’m Not the Man I Used to Be”) to joyful 1960s soul (“Good Thing,” “Tell Me What”) and back. Roland Gift’s voice, one of the most distinctive of its era, holds everything together.

Its main weakness is that three of its ten songs had already been released before the album, so it can feel a bit like a compilation. Some of the deep cuts on side two are weaker than the singles.

Highlights: “She Drives Me Crazy,” “Good Thing,” “I’m Not the Man I Used to Be,” “Ever Fallen in Love.”
Weakest moment: “Don’t Let It Get You Down.” It’s pleasant but forgettable.

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.