Vinyl Review

Fleetwood Mac — 1975–1987

By ·

Fleetwood Mac — 1975–1987

6LP box set on crystal-clear vinyl · Label: Rhino / Warner · Released: 28 March 2025
Contents: Fleetwood Mac (1975), Rumours (1977), Tusk (1979, 2LP), Mirage (1982), Tango in the Night (1987)


Why I Bought It

I already owned Rumours and Tango in the Night, so this box was never going to be entirely new to me. But the chance to get the classic Buckingham–Nicks era in one matching set on crystal-clear vinyl, and finally fill the gaps with the 1975 album, Tusk and Mirage, was too tempting.

So for me, this box is really about three albums. Rumours and Tango are duplicates, now in clear vinyl.


Background

In late 1974, Fleetwood Mac were a struggling British blues band with a constantly changing lineup. Then Mick Fleetwood visited Sound City Studios in Van Nuys and heard “Frozen Love” by an unknown duo, Lindsey Buckingham and Stevie Nicks. He invited Buckingham to join, and Buckingham agreed on the condition that Nicks came too.

Over the next twelve years, the lineup of Mick Fleetwood, John McVie, Christine McVie, Buckingham and Nicks made five albums that sold in enormous numbers. They did it through divorces, affairs, addiction and constant fighting. Buckingham’s departure in 1987 ended the era, and that’s exactly what this box covers.


The Albums

Fleetwood Mac (1975) — new to me

Producers: Fleetwood Mac and Keith Olsen · Recorded at: Sound City, Van Nuys

The first album by the new lineup. It took more than a year to reach US No. 1, and it established the band’s formula: Christine’s warm pop, Nicks’s mystical songs and Buckingham’s sharp arrangements.

Side One: Monday Morning · Warm Ways · Blue Letter · Rhiannon · Over My Head · Crystal
Side Two: Say You Love Me · Landslide · World Turning · Sugar Daddy · I’m So Afraid

Highlights are “Rhiannon,” Nicks’s breakthrough song about a Welsh witch; “Landslide,” her beautiful reflection on change; and “I’m So Afraid,” Buckingham’s brooding epic with its searing solo. “Over My Head” and “Say You Love Me” were Christine’s first big US hits with the band.


Rumours (1977) — already owned

One of the best-selling albums ever, written while the band’s relationships collapsed around them. I already had it, so this copy is a duplicate.

Side One: Second Hand News · Dreams · Never Going Back Again · Don’t Stop · Go Your Own Way · Songbird
Side Two: The Chain · You Make Loving Fun · I Don’t Want to Know · Oh Daddy · Gold Dust Woman


Tusk (1979, 2LP) — new to me

Producers: Fleetwood Mac, Ken Caillat and Richard Dashut

Buckingham’s rebellion against the Rumours formula. It’s a sprawling 20-track double album, influenced by punk and new wave, with many of his songs recorded at home. It was seen as a commercial disappointment at the time, but it’s now regarded as their most adventurous record.

Side A: Over & Over · The Ledge · Think About Me · Save Me a Place · Sara
Side B: What Makes You Think You’re the One · Storms · That’s All for Everyone · Not That Funny · Sisters of the Moon
Side C: Angel · That’s Enough for Me · Brown Eyes · Never Make Me Cry · I Know I’m Not Wrong
Side D: Honey Hi · Beautiful Child · Walk a Thin Line · Tusk · Never Forget

Highlights are “Sara,” Nicks’s dreamy six-minute song; “Storms,” a haunting Nicks song; “Tusk,” with the USC Trojan Marching Band recorded at Dodger Stadium; and Christine’s lovely closer “Never Forget.” Peter Green reportedly plays, uncredited, on “Brown Eyes.”


Mirage (1982) — new to me

Producers: Fleetwood Mac, Ken Caillat, Richard Dashut · Recorded at: the Château d’Hérouville, France, and Los Angeles

A deliberate return to the polished sound of Rumours. It’s often seen as the weakest album of the era, but it has some excellent songs.

Side One: Love in Store · Can’t Go Back · That’s Alright · Book of Love · Gypsy · Only Over You
Side Two: Empire State · Straight Back · Hold Me · Oh Diane · Eyes of the World · Wish You Were Here

Highlights are “Gypsy,” one of Nicks’s best and most nostalgic songs; “Hold Me,” Christine’s sunny US Top 5 hit; and the wistful closer “Wish You Were Here.”


Tango in the Night (1987) — already owned

Producers: Lindsey Buckingham and Richard Dashut · Recorded at: Buckingham’s home studio, The Slope

This lineup’s last album. It’s a glossy, atmospheric 1980s pop record and a huge success, especially in the UK. Buckingham left soon afterwards. I already had this one too, so it’s another duplicate.

Side One: Big Love · Seven Wonders · Everywhere · Caroline · Tango in the Night · Mystified
Side Two: Little Lies · Family Man · Welcome to the Room… Sara · Isn’t It Midnight · When I See You Again · You and I, Part II


The Box Itself

The vinyl

The crystal-clear vinyl looks great on the turntable. Clear vinyl contains no pigment, and it’s generally considered one of the quieter coloured-vinyl options. In fact I prefer clear vinyl over black, the black still being a dye, just like any other coloured record.

The sleeves: my main complaint

This is where the box let me down. Rumours came with a proper poly-lined inner sleeve, but every other album came in a plain card sleeve. I honestly don’t understand why one album was treated better than the rest.

Card sleeves can scuff and scratch records every time you slide one in or out, and they shed paper dust onto the grooves. Clear vinyl shows marks more easily, so the problem is even more noticeable. I ended up buying poly-lined inner sleeves and fitting them myself to protect the records.

At a price of roughly £150, that’s not acceptable. Proper anti-static inner sleeves cost the label very little, and a premium box set should include them for every disc, not just the one album most people already own.

My other minor gripe was that the albums were not in order within the box set itself. A very minor detail and easily rectified once the shrink wrap was off.

Value

For me, the value is mixed. As a complete set, it’s good value compared with buying five albums separately. But because I already owned Rumours and Tango in the Night, I effectively paid box-set money for three albums, two of which I’d consider essential (Fleetwood Mac and Tusk), plus duplicates. Anyone who doesn’t own any of these albums will get much more out of it.

Extras

There are no bonus tracks in the standard box. A Rhino.com exclusive edition included a bonus crystal-clear 12″ of “Silver Springs” and “Go Your Own Way” in stereo and mono, limited to 1,000 copies. [Say whether yours included it.]


Final Thoughts

The music in this box is outstanding. Even Mirage, the weakest album, has classics, and Fleetwood Mac (1975) and Tuskwere the real finds for me. The crystal-clear vinyl looks the part.

But the packaging lets it down. Giving Rumours a poly-lined sleeve and putting the rest in bare card is an odd, cheap decision for a premium-priced box, and it meant extra time and money on my part to protect the records properly.

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.