Vinyl Review

Evanescence — The Open Door (2006)

By ·

evanescence album cover

This copy: Craft Recordings 00888072835993 · 2LP 20th Anniversary Deluxe Edition · Remastered · Gatefold · Translucent cobalt vinyl · Europe · Released 6 November 2026

Producer: Dave Fortman · Original release: October 2006, Wind-up Records


Introduction

Few bands had a debut like Evanescence's. Fallen (2003), with "Bring Me to Life" and "My Immortal," sold millions and made Amy Lee one of the most recognisable voices in rock. Then, partway through the Fallen tour, co-founder and guitarist Ben Moody walked out. Many people assumed the band was finished.

The Open Door was Amy Lee's answer. She wrote it largely with new guitarist Terry Balsamo, and this time she had control of the band's direction. It's darker, heavier, more orchestral and more personal than Fallen, and it was a huge success, debuting at No. 1 on the US Billboard 200.

This 20th anniversary deluxe edition from Craft Recordings remasters the album and adds four bonus tracks.


Track Listing

The original album

1. Sweet Sacrifice
A crushing, dramatic opener that sets the tone, with heavy riffs, strings, and Lee's voice soaring above it. It was released as a single.

2. Call Me When You're Sober
The lead single and the album's best-known song. It's an angry, defiant break-up song, widely reported to be about her former boyfriend, Seether singer Shaun Morgan. Its fairy-tale video is inspired by Little Red Riding Hood. It reached the US Top 10.

3. Weight of the World
A heavy, driving song about pressure and expectation.

4. Lithium
A slow, piano-led ballad that builds to a heavy climax. It's about clinging to sadness rather than numbing it. Not to be confused with the Nirvana song of the same name. It was a single.

5. Cloud Nine
A brooding, electronic-tinged track.

6. Snow White Queen
A dark, unsettling song inspired by Lee's experience of being stalked by an obsessive fan. It's one of the album's most chilling moments.

7. Lacrymosa
Built on the "Lacrimosa" from Mozart's Requiem, with choir and orchestra. It's the band's most classical moment, and one of the album's highlights.

8. Like You
A grieving, emotional song about Lee's younger sister, who died as a small child. It's one of the most personal songs she has written.

9. Lose Control
A heavy, desperate song.

10. The Only One
A pounding, aggressive track.

11. Your Star
A haunting, atmospheric song with a sense of loss and abandonment.

12. All That I'm Living For
A soaring, anthemic song about longing and dependence.

13. Good Enough
The closing piano ballad and final single. It's gentle and hopeful, a rare moment of peace, and one of Amy Lee's best songs.

The 20th anniversary bonus tracks

  • If You Don't Mind: a B-side from the era.
  • Together Again: a song from the sessions that was released later, reportedly in 2010 to raise money for Haiti earthquake relief.
  • The Last Song I'm Wasting on You: a B-side from the "Call Me When You're Sober" single. It's a fan favourite.
  • Good Enough (Demo Version): previously unreleased. It's a glimpse of the closing track in its early form.

Enthusiast Details

  • Production: producer Dave Fortman had also mixed Fallen, and he later produced Slipknot and Simple Plan. He gave the album its big, heavy, orchestral sound, combining metal guitars with strings, choir, piano and electronics.
  • The band: Amy Lee (vocals, piano, keyboards), Terry Balsamo (guitar), John LeCompt (guitar), Rocky Gray(drums) and Will Boyd (bass).
  • Taking control: Lee has said she felt freer writing this album than Fallen. It shows in the album's range, from Mozart to piano ballads to heavy riffs.
  • Why Craft: Evanescence's Wind-up Records catalogue is now owned by Concord, and Craft Recordings is Concord's catalogue reissue label. Craft also released the Isaac Hayes compilation you reviewed earlier.

Vinyl variants

The anniversary edition came in several colours:

  • Midnight Nebula: sold through the Evanescence store.
  • Metallic Blue: sold through Craft Recordings.
  • Mercury Blend and Opaque Ivory: sold through independent shops.
  • Ghost: a Books-A-Million exclusive, limited to 500 copies.
  • Black: the standard edition.

The sources I found don't mention translucent cobalt, which is my copy's colour. So it may be a European or retailer-specific variant. I have had this happen before.


Final Thoughts

The Open Door is the sound of Amy Lee taking control. It's darker, heavier and more ambitious than Fallen, and in places more personal. "Call Me When You're Sober," "Lacrymosa," "Lithium," "Like You" and "Good Enough" are among the band's best songs. The album can feel long and a little samey in its heavier middle section, where songs like "Lose Control" and "The Only One" blur together.

The anniversary edition is a worthwhile upgrade, with a new remaster, a deluxe gatefold and four bonus tracks, including the unreleased "Good Enough" demo.

Highlights: "Call Me When You're Sober," "Lacrymosa," "Lithium," "Like You," "Good Enough."
Weakest moments: "Lose Control," "The Only One."

Buy this record at Boiler Room Records, delivers to UK only (opens in a new tab) Buy this record at Pandemonium, delivers to UK only (opens in a new tab)

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.