Vinyl Review

Paul McCartney — Pipes of Peace (1983)

By ·

Paul McCartney — Pipes of Peace (1983)

My copy: Parlophone / MPL PCTC 1652301 · LP · Stereo · Gatefold · UK · 31 October 1983

Producer: George Martin · Bought: on a crate-digging session at The Den in Poole


A Childhood Favourite, Found at The Den

This was another find from my crate-digging session at The Den in Poole, and another one that took me straight back to being a kid.

Pipes of Peace was a favourite of mine before I was even a teenager. Alongside "We All Stand Together," better known to most of us as "The Frog Song" from Rupert and the Frog Song, it was one of the records that made Paul McCartney part of my childhood. The title track in particular, with its children's choir and that unforgettable Christmas video, was a song I played over and over.

Coming across a clean UK gatefold copy in the crates was a real pleasure. Like The Jazz Singer, it felt less like buying a record and more like getting a bit of my childhood back.


Introduction

Pipes of Peace is the companion album to Tug of War (1982), which was widely praised as McCartney's best solo work since Band on the Run. Much of Pipes of Peace came from the same sessions, at George Martin's AIR Studios in London and on Montserrat, with Martin again producing.

It didn't get the same critical welcome. Reviewers found it lightweight compared with Tug of War, and it's often overlooked today. But it was a commercial success, reaching UK No. 4, and it contains two of the biggest hits of McCartney's solo career: the title track and "Say Say Say," his duet with Michael Jackson.


Track Listing

Side One

1. Pipes of Peace
A gentle, hopeful song about peace and understanding, with Indian instruments, a children's choir and a big, sweeping chorus. It went to UK No. 1 in January 1984. Its video recreated the 1914 Christmas truce in the trenches of the First World War, with McCartney playing both a British and a German soldier who meet in no man's land. It's one of the most memorable videos of the 1980s, and one of his most moving songs.

2. Say Say Say (with Michael Jackson)
A bright, funky duet, and the second time the pair worked together after "The Girl Is Mine" on Thriller. It spent six weeks at US No. 1 and reached UK No. 2. The video cast them as a pair of travelling con men selling a fake potion, "Mac and Jack," with Linda McCartney and La Toya Jackson also appearing.

3. The Other Me
A wistful, slightly rueful love song about wanting to be a better person for someone. It has a gentle synth-pop feel.

4. Keep Under Cover
A busy, dramatic song with shifting sections, and one of the album's more ambitious tracks.

5. So Bad
A tender ballad sung largely in McCartney's falsetto. In the US, it was released as the A-side of the single instead of "Pipes of Peace."

Side Two

6. The Man (with Michael Jackson)
The second McCartney–Jackson duet on the album. It's a warm, upbeat song, and less well known than "Say Say Say."

7. Sweetest Little Show
A light, acoustic song with a playful guitar solo and a tongue-in-cheek feel.

8. Average Person
A cheerful, music-hall-flavoured song in McCartney's storytelling style, about ordinary people and their dreams.

9. Hey Hey
An instrumental co-written with the jazz bassist Stanley Clarke, built around his funky bass playing.

10. Tug of Peace
A percussion-heavy track that links the two albums, combining the title of Tug of War with Pipes of Peace.

11. Through Our Love
A grand, orchestral closer arranged by George Martin.


Enthusiast Details

  • George Martin: the Beatles' producer worked with McCartney on both Tug of War and Pipes of Peace. His orchestral arrangements are a big part of the album's sound.
  • Michael Jackson: the two collaborations were recorded in 1981 and 1983, before Jackson bought the ATV publishing catalogue in 1985, which included the rights to most Beatles songs. The purchase strained their friendship.
  • Stanley Clarke: the jazz-fusion bassist, known for Return to Forever, plays on several tracks.
  • The children's choir: the choir on the title track came from the Pestalozzi Children's Village, an international children's charity in Sussex.
  • "We All Stand Together": the Frog Song wasn't on this album. It was released as a single in late 1984, reached UK No. 3 and went with McCartney's animated film Rupert and the Frog Song. It came from the same period, though, and was part of the same run of McCartney songs that were on the radio and television throughout the mid-1980s.
  • My copy: the original UK Parlophone pressing, catalogue PCTC 1652301, in a gatefold sleeve. Copies are common and affordable, which makes it a perfect crate-digging find.

Final Thoughts

Pipes of Peace will never be held up as one of McCartney's great albums. It's lighter and less consistent than Tug of War, and some songs, like "Tug of Peace" and "Keep Under Cover," are slight. But the title track is one of his most beautiful and meaningful songs, "Say Say Say" is great fun, and "So Bad" and "Through Our Love" are lovely ballads.

For me, though, this album isn't about critical rankings. It was one of my favourites as a youngster, and hearing it again, rescued from a crate at The Den in Poole, was a real joy.

Highlights: "Pipes of Peace," "Say Say Say," "So Bad," "Through Our Love."
Weakest moments: "Tug of Peace," "Keep Under Cover."

Rating: 3.5 / 5 for the album. As a piece of my childhood: 5 / 5.

Get new reviews by email

An occasional email from Phil when new reviews go up. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Your email is only used for these updates. How your details are kept.