Simon & Garfunkel — Sounds of Silence (1966)

My copy: Columbia PC 9269 · LP · Promo · Stereo · US
Producer: Bob Johnston · Bought: on a crate-digging session at The Den in Poole
Found at The Den
This was another record from my crate-digging session at The Den in Poole, and a bit of a surprise: an American Columbia pressing marked as a promo. Promo copies were sent out to radio stations and reviewers rather than sold in shops. Finding one of these, all these years later, in a shop on the south coast of England is exactly why crate digging is so much fun.
Introduction
Simon & Garfunkel's career very nearly ended before it began. Their first album, Wednesday Morning, 3 A.M. (1964), was a quiet acoustic folk record that barely sold. The duo split up, and Paul Simon moved to England, where he played the folk club circuit and recorded a solo album, The Paul Simon Songbook (1965).
Then, back in New York, their producer Tom Wilson did something that changed everything. Without telling them, he took their acoustic recording of "The Sound of Silence," overdubbed electric guitar, bass and drums, and released it as a single. That folk-rock version went to US No. 1 at the start of 1966.
Columbia rushed out an album to follow it. Simon came home, the duo reunited, and they quickly recorded Sounds of Silence. Many of its songs were new band arrangements of material Simon had recorded alone in England. It reached the US Top 30 and launched one of the most successful duos in pop history.
Track Listing
Side One
1. The Sound of Silence
The song that made them. Simon's lyric, about people who can't communicate, is one of the defining songs of the 1960s, and the duo's close harmonies are beautiful. The electric overdubs were played by session musicians who had also worked on Bob Dylan's recordings. The album is titled Sounds of Silence, but the song is "The Sound of Silence."
2. Leaves That Are Green
A wistful, gentle song about time passing and youth slipping away, with a harpsichord-like keyboard.
3. Blessed
A darker, angrier song, inspired by the Beatitudes, about the people society forgets.
4. Kathy's Song
A tender, acoustic love song for Kathy Chitty, Simon's English girlfriend, written while he was living in England. It's one of the most beautiful songs he wrote.
5. Somewhere They Can't Find Me
A driving folk-rock song about a young man on the run, which reworks the melody of their earlier song "Wednesday Morning, 3 A.M."
6. Anji
A short acoustic guitar instrumental, written by the British folk guitarist Davey Graham. It's a classic of the British folk scene, and Simon learned it in England.
Side Two
7. Richard Cory
Based on Edwin Arlington Robinson's poem about a wealthy, envied man who takes his own life. Simon turns it into an upbeat folk-rock song, with a dark twist in the chorus.
8. A Most Peculiar Man
A quiet, sad song about a lonely man and his death, observed by his neighbours.
9. April Come She Will
A short, delicate song that follows a love affair through the months of the year, sung by Art Garfunkel. It later became famous through The Graduate (1967).
10. We've Got a Groovy Thing Goin'
An upbeat folk-rock song, originally the B-side of "The Sound of Silence."
11. I Am a Rock
A defiant song about shutting yourself off from love to avoid getting hurt. It became another US Top 3 hit, and a strong ending to the album.
Enthusiast Details
- Two producers: Tom Wilson created the electric version of "The Sound of Silence." He also produced Bob Dylan and the Velvet Underground. Bob Johnston produced the rest of the album. He later produced Dylan's Blonde on Blonde and Johnny Cash's prison albums.
- The Paul Simon Songbook: several songs on this album, including "Kathy's Song," "Leaves That Are Green," "A Most Peculiar Man," "April Come She Will," "I Am a Rock" and "The Sound of Silence," first appeared on Simon's solo album, recorded in London in 1965.
- What came next: Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme (1966), Bookends (1968) and Bridge over Troubled Water(1970), along with the soundtrack to The Graduate, which used "The Sound of Silence" and "April Come She Will."
- My copy: the catalogue number PC 9269 uses Columbia's "PC" prefix, which the label introduced in the 1970s for reissues of its catalogue. The original 1966 stereo pressing was CS 9269. So although Discogs lists 1965, this is a later US reissue of the album, and the promo marking means it was sent out for radio or review rather than sold in shops.
Final Thoughts
Sounds of Silence is an album made in a hurry to follow a surprise hit, and it sometimes shows. A few songs, like "We've Got a Groovy Thing Goin'," feel less substantial, and the folk-rock arrangements don't always suit Simon's more delicate songs as well as the solo versions did.
But it's full of great songwriting. "The Sound of Silence," "Kathy's Song," "I Am a Rock," "April Come She Will" and "Richard Cory" show Paul Simon finding his voice as one of the great songwriters of his generation, and the duo's harmonies are already extraordinary.
Finding an American promo copy in a crate at The Den in Poole made it all the more special.
Highlights: "The Sound of Silence," "Kathy's Song," "I Am a Rock," "April Come She Will," "Richard Cory."
Weakest moment: "We've Got a Groovy Thing Goin'."
Rating: 4 / 5.